Home | History | Annotate | Line # | Download | only in util
      1  1.1.1.15  christos .Dd May 25 2024
      2       1.1  christos .Dt NTP_KEYGEN 1ntp-keygenmdoc User Commands
      3   1.1.1.2  christos .Os
      4       1.1  christos .\"  EDIT THIS FILE WITH CAUTION  (ntp-keygen-opts.mdoc)
      5       1.1  christos .\"
      6  1.1.1.15  christos .\"  It has been AutoGen-ed  May 25, 2024 at 12:04:46 AM by AutoGen 5.18.16
      7       1.1  christos .\"  From the definitions    ntp-keygen-opts.def
      8       1.1  christos .\"  and the template file   agmdoc-cmd.tpl
      9       1.1  christos .Sh NAME
     10       1.1  christos .Nm ntp-keygen
     11       1.1  christos .Nd Create a NTP host key
     12       1.1  christos .Sh SYNOPSIS
     13       1.1  christos .Nm
     14       1.1  christos .\" Mixture of short (flag) options and long options
     15       1.1  christos .Op Fl flags
     16       1.1  christos .Op Fl flag Op Ar value
     17       1.1  christos .Op Fl \-option\-name Ns Oo Oo Ns "=| " Oc Ns Ar value Oc
     18       1.1  christos .Pp
     19       1.1  christos All arguments must be options.
     20       1.1  christos .Pp
     21       1.1  christos .Sh DESCRIPTION
     22       1.1  christos This program generates cryptographic data files used by the NTPv4
     23       1.1  christos authentication and identification schemes.
     24  1.1.1.11  christos It can generate message digest keys used in symmetric key cryptography and,
     25  1.1.1.11  christos if the OpenSSL software library has been installed, it can generate host keys,
     26  1.1.1.11  christos signing keys, certificates, and identity keys and parameters used in Autokey
     27  1.1.1.11  christos public key cryptography.
     28       1.1  christos These files are used for cookie encryption,
     29  1.1.1.11  christos digital signature, and challenge/response identification algorithms
     30       1.1  christos compatible with the Internet standard security infrastructure.
     31       1.1  christos .Pp
     32  1.1.1.11  christos The message digest symmetric keys file is generated in a format
     33  1.1.1.11  christos compatible with NTPv3.
     34  1.1.1.11  christos All other files are in PEM\-encoded printable ASCII format,
     35  1.1.1.11  christos so they can be embedded as MIME attachments in email to other sites
     36       1.1  christos and certificate authorities.
     37       1.1  christos By default, files are not encrypted.
     38       1.1  christos .Pp
     39  1.1.1.11  christos When used to generate message digest symmetric keys, the program
     40  1.1.1.11  christos produces a file containing ten pseudo\-random printable ASCII strings
     41  1.1.1.11  christos suitable for the MD5 message digest algorithm included in the
     42  1.1.1.11  christos distribution.
     43       1.1  christos If the OpenSSL library is installed, it produces an additional ten
     44  1.1.1.11  christos hex\-encoded random bit strings suitable for SHA1, AES\-128\-CMAC, and
     45  1.1.1.11  christos other message digest algorithms.
     46  1.1.1.11  christos The message digest symmetric keys file must be distributed and stored
     47       1.1  christos using secure means beyond the scope of NTP itself.
     48       1.1  christos Besides the keys used for ordinary NTP associations, additional keys
     49       1.1  christos can be defined as passwords for the
     50       1.1  christos .Xr ntpq 1ntpqmdoc
     51       1.1  christos and
     52       1.1  christos .Xr ntpdc 1ntpdcmdoc
     53       1.1  christos utility programs.
     54       1.1  christos .Pp
     55       1.1  christos The remaining generated files are compatible with other OpenSSL
     56       1.1  christos applications and other Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) resources.
     57       1.1  christos Certificates generated by this program are compatible with extant
     58       1.1  christos industry practice, although some users might find the interpretation of
     59       1.1  christos X509v3 extension fields somewhat liberal.
     60       1.1  christos However, the identity keys are probably not compatible with anything
     61       1.1  christos other than Autokey.
     62       1.1  christos .Pp
     63       1.1  christos Some files used by this program are encrypted using a private password.
     64       1.1  christos The
     65       1.1  christos .Fl p
     66  1.1.1.11  christos option specifies the read password for local encrypted files and the
     67       1.1  christos .Fl q
     68  1.1.1.11  christos option the write password for encrypted files sent to remote sites.
     69       1.1  christos If no password is specified, the host name returned by the Unix
     70  1.1.1.11  christos .Xr hostname 1
     71  1.1.1.11  christos command, normally the DNS name of the host, is used as the the default read
     72  1.1.1.11  christos password, for convenience.
     73  1.1.1.11  christos The
     74  1.1.1.11  christos .Nm
     75  1.1.1.11  christos program prompts for the password if it reads an encrypted file
     76  1.1.1.11  christos and the password is missing or incorrect.
     77  1.1.1.11  christos If an encrypted file is read successfully and
     78  1.1.1.11  christos no write password is specified, the read password is used
     79  1.1.1.11  christos as the write password by default.
     80       1.1  christos .Pp
     81       1.1  christos The
     82  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm pw
     83       1.1  christos option of the
     84  1.1.1.11  christos .Ic crypto
     85  1.1.1.11  christos .Xr ntpd 1ntpdmdoc
     86       1.1  christos configuration command specifies the read
     87       1.1  christos password for previously encrypted local files.
     88  1.1.1.11  christos This must match the local read password used by this program.
     89       1.1  christos If not specified, the host name is used.
     90  1.1.1.11  christos Thus, if files are generated by this program without an explicit password,
     91       1.1  christos they can be read back by
     92  1.1.1.11  christos .Xr ntpd 1ntpdmdoc
     93  1.1.1.11  christos without specifying an explicit password but only on the same host.
     94  1.1.1.11  christos If the write password used for encryption is specified as the host name,
     95  1.1.1.11  christos these files can be read by that host with no explicit password.
     96       1.1  christos .Pp
     97       1.1  christos Normally, encrypted files for each host are generated by that host and
     98       1.1  christos used only by that host, although exceptions exist as noted later on
     99       1.1  christos this page.
    100       1.1  christos The symmetric keys file, normally called
    101  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntp.keys ,
    102       1.1  christos is usually installed in
    103       1.1  christos .Pa /etc .
    104       1.1  christos Other files and links are usually installed in
    105       1.1  christos .Pa /usr/local/etc ,
    106       1.1  christos which is normally in a shared filesystem in
    107       1.1  christos NFS\-mounted networks and cannot be changed by shared clients.
    108  1.1.1.11  christos In these cases, NFS clients can specify the files in another
    109  1.1.1.11  christos directory such as
    110  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa /etc
    111  1.1.1.11  christos using the
    112  1.1.1.11  christos .Ic keysdir
    113  1.1.1.11  christos .Xr ntpd 1ntpdmdoc
    114  1.1.1.11  christos configuration file command.
    115       1.1  christos .Pp
    116       1.1  christos This program directs commentary and error messages to the standard
    117       1.1  christos error stream
    118  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa stderr
    119       1.1  christos and remote files to the standard output stream
    120  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa stdout
    121       1.1  christos where they can be piped to other applications or redirected to files.
    122       1.1  christos The names used for generated files and links all begin with the
    123       1.1  christos string
    124  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey\&*
    125       1.1  christos and include the file type, generating host and filestamp,
    126       1.1  christos as described in the
    127  1.1.1.11  christos .Sx "Cryptographic Data Files"
    128       1.1  christos section below.
    129       1.1  christos .Ss Running the Program
    130       1.1  christos The safest way to run the
    131       1.1  christos .Nm
    132       1.1  christos program is logged in directly as root.
    133  1.1.1.11  christos The recommended procedure is change to the
    134  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar keys
    135  1.1.1.11  christos directory, usually
    136       1.1  christos .Pa /usr/local/etc ,
    137       1.1  christos then run the program.
    138  1.1.1.11  christos .Pp
    139  1.1.1.11  christos To test and gain experience with Autokey concepts, log in as root and
    140  1.1.1.11  christos change to the
    141  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar keys
    142  1.1.1.11  christos directory, usually
    143  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa /usr/local/etc .
    144  1.1.1.11  christos When run for the first time, or if all files with names beginning with
    145  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey\&*
    146  1.1.1.11  christos have been removed, use the
    147  1.1.1.11  christos .Nm
    148  1.1.1.11  christos command without arguments to generate a default
    149  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm RSA
    150  1.1.1.11  christos host key and matching
    151  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm RSA\-MD5
    152  1.1.1.11  christos certificate file with expiration date one year hence,
    153       1.1  christos which is all that is necessary in many cases.
    154       1.1  christos The program also generates soft links from the generic names
    155       1.1  christos to the respective files.
    156  1.1.1.11  christos If run again without options, the program uses the
    157  1.1.1.11  christos existing keys and parameters and generates a new certificate file with
    158  1.1.1.11  christos new expiration date one year hence, and soft link.
    159       1.1  christos .Pp
    160  1.1.1.11  christos The host key is used to encrypt the cookie when required and so must be
    161  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm RSA
    162  1.1.1.11  christos type.
    163       1.1  christos By default, the host key is also the sign key used to encrypt signatures.
    164       1.1  christos When necessary, a different sign key can be specified and this can be
    165  1.1.1.11  christos either
    166  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm RSA
    167  1.1.1.11  christos or
    168  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm DSA
    169  1.1.1.11  christos type.
    170  1.1.1.11  christos By default, the message digest type is
    171  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm MD5 ,
    172  1.1.1.11  christos but any combination
    173       1.1  christos of sign key type and message digest type supported by the OpenSSL library
    174  1.1.1.11  christos can be specified, including those using the
    175  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm AES128CMAC , MD2 , MD5 , MDC2 , SHA , SHA1
    176  1.1.1.11  christos and
    177  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm RIPE160
    178  1.1.1.11  christos message digest algorithms.
    179       1.1  christos However, the scheme specified in the certificate must be compatible
    180       1.1  christos with the sign key.
    181  1.1.1.11  christos Certificates using any digest algorithm are compatible with
    182  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm RSA
    183  1.1.1.11  christos sign keys;
    184  1.1.1.11  christos however, only
    185  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm SHA
    186  1.1.1.11  christos and
    187  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm SHA1
    188  1.1.1.11  christos certificates are compatible with
    189  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm DSA
    190  1.1.1.11  christos sign keys.
    191       1.1  christos .Pp
    192       1.1  christos Private/public key files and certificates are compatible with
    193       1.1  christos other OpenSSL applications and very likely other libraries as well.
    194       1.1  christos Certificates or certificate requests derived from them should be compatible
    195       1.1  christos with extant industry practice, although some users might find
    196       1.1  christos the interpretation of X509v3 extension fields somewhat liberal.
    197       1.1  christos However, the identification parameter files, although encoded
    198       1.1  christos as the other files, are probably not compatible with anything other than Autokey.
    199       1.1  christos .Pp
    200       1.1  christos Running the program as other than root and using the Unix
    201  1.1.1.11  christos .Xr su 1
    202       1.1  christos command
    203       1.1  christos to assume root may not work properly, since by default the OpenSSL library
    204       1.1  christos looks for the random seed file
    205  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa .rnd
    206       1.1  christos in the user home directory.
    207       1.1  christos However, there should be only one
    208  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa .rnd ,
    209       1.1  christos most conveniently
    210       1.1  christos in the root directory, so it is convenient to define the
    211  1.1.1.11  christos .Ev RANDFILE
    212       1.1  christos environment variable used by the OpenSSL library as the path to
    213  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa .rnd .
    214       1.1  christos .Pp
    215       1.1  christos Installing the keys as root might not work in NFS\-mounted
    216       1.1  christos shared file systems, as NFS clients may not be able to write
    217       1.1  christos to the shared keys directory, even as root.
    218       1.1  christos In this case, NFS clients can specify the files in another
    219       1.1  christos directory such as
    220       1.1  christos .Pa /etc
    221       1.1  christos using the
    222       1.1  christos .Ic keysdir
    223  1.1.1.11  christos .Xr ntpd 1ntpdmdoc
    224  1.1.1.11  christos configuration file command.
    225       1.1  christos There is no need for one client to read the keys and certificates
    226       1.1  christos of other clients or servers, as these data are obtained automatically
    227       1.1  christos by the Autokey protocol.
    228       1.1  christos .Pp
    229       1.1  christos Ordinarily, cryptographic files are generated by the host that uses them,
    230       1.1  christos but it is possible for a trusted agent (TA) to generate these files
    231       1.1  christos for other hosts; however, in such cases files should always be encrypted.
    232       1.1  christos The subject name and trusted name default to the hostname
    233       1.1  christos of the host generating the files, but can be changed by command line options.
    234       1.1  christos It is convenient to designate the owner name and trusted name
    235       1.1  christos as the subject and issuer fields, respectively, of the certificate.
    236       1.1  christos The owner name is also used for the host and sign key files,
    237       1.1  christos while the trusted name is used for the identity files.
    238       1.1  christos .Pp
    239       1.1  christos All files are installed by default in the keys directory
    240       1.1  christos .Pa /usr/local/etc ,
    241       1.1  christos which is normally in a shared filesystem
    242       1.1  christos in NFS\-mounted networks.
    243       1.1  christos The actual location of the keys directory
    244       1.1  christos and each file can be overridden by configuration commands,
    245       1.1  christos but this is not recommended.
    246       1.1  christos Normally, the files for each host are generated by that host
    247       1.1  christos and used only by that host, although exceptions exist
    248       1.1  christos as noted later on this page.
    249       1.1  christos .Pp
    250       1.1  christos Normally, files containing private values,
    251       1.1  christos including the host key, sign key and identification parameters,
    252       1.1  christos are permitted root read/write\-only;
    253       1.1  christos while others containing public values are permitted world readable.
    254       1.1  christos Alternatively, files containing private values can be encrypted
    255       1.1  christos and these files permitted world readable,
    256       1.1  christos which simplifies maintenance in shared file systems.
    257  1.1.1.11  christos Since uniqueness is insured by the
    258  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar hostname
    259  1.1.1.11  christos and
    260  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar filestamp
    261  1.1.1.11  christos file name extensions, the files for an NTP server and
    262       1.1  christos dependent clients can all be installed in the same shared directory.
    263       1.1  christos .Pp
    264       1.1  christos The recommended practice is to keep the file name extensions
    265       1.1  christos when installing a file and to install a soft link
    266       1.1  christos from the generic names specified elsewhere on this page
    267       1.1  christos to the generated files.
    268       1.1  christos This allows new file generations to be activated simply
    269       1.1  christos by changing the link.
    270  1.1.1.11  christos If a link is present,
    271  1.1.1.11  christos .Xr ntpd 1ntpdmdoc
    272  1.1.1.11  christos follows it to the file name to extract the
    273  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar filestamp .
    274       1.1  christos If a link is not present,
    275       1.1  christos .Xr ntpd 1ntpdmdoc
    276  1.1.1.11  christos extracts the
    277  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar filestamp
    278  1.1.1.11  christos from the file itself.
    279       1.1  christos This allows clients to verify that the file and generation times
    280       1.1  christos are always current.
    281       1.1  christos The
    282       1.1  christos .Nm
    283  1.1.1.11  christos program uses the same
    284  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar filestamp
    285  1.1.1.11  christos extension for all files generated
    286       1.1  christos at one time, so each generation is distinct and can be readily
    287       1.1  christos recognized in monitoring data.
    288  1.1.1.11  christos .Pp
    289  1.1.1.11  christos Run the command on as many hosts as necessary.
    290  1.1.1.11  christos Designate one of them as the trusted host (TH) using
    291       1.1  christos .Nm
    292  1.1.1.11  christos with the
    293  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl T
    294  1.1.1.11  christos option and configure it to synchronize from reliable Internet servers.
    295  1.1.1.11  christos Then configure the other hosts to synchronize to the TH directly or
    296  1.1.1.11  christos indirectly.
    297  1.1.1.11  christos A certificate trail is created when Autokey asks the immediately
    298  1.1.1.11  christos ascendant host towards the TH to sign its certificate, which is then
    299  1.1.1.11  christos provided to the immediately descendant host on request.
    300  1.1.1.11  christos All group hosts should have acyclic certificate trails ending on the TH.
    301       1.1  christos .Pp
    302  1.1.1.11  christos The host key is used to encrypt the cookie when required and so must be
    303  1.1.1.11  christos RSA type.
    304  1.1.1.11  christos By default, the host key is also the sign key used to encrypt
    305  1.1.1.11  christos signatures.
    306  1.1.1.11  christos A different sign key can be assigned using the
    307  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl S
    308  1.1.1.11  christos option and this can be either
    309  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm RSA
    310  1.1.1.11  christos or
    311  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm DSA
    312  1.1.1.11  christos type.
    313  1.1.1.11  christos By default, the signature
    314  1.1.1.11  christos message digest type is
    315  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm MD5 ,
    316  1.1.1.11  christos but any combination of sign key type and
    317  1.1.1.11  christos message digest type supported by the OpenSSL library can be specified
    318  1.1.1.11  christos using the
    319  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl c
    320  1.1.1.11  christos option.
    321       1.1  christos .Pp
    322  1.1.1.11  christos The rules say cryptographic media should be generated with proventic
    323  1.1.1.11  christos filestamps, which means the host should already be synchronized before
    324  1.1.1.11  christos this program is run.
    325  1.1.1.11  christos This of course creates a chicken\-and\-egg problem
    326  1.1.1.11  christos when the host is started for the first time.
    327  1.1.1.11  christos Accordingly, the host time
    328  1.1.1.11  christos should be set by some other means, such as eyeball\-and\-wristwatch, at
    329  1.1.1.11  christos least so that the certificate lifetime is within the current year.
    330  1.1.1.11  christos After that and when the host is synchronized to a proventic source, the
    331  1.1.1.11  christos certificate should be re\-generated.
    332       1.1  christos .Pp
    333  1.1.1.11  christos Additional information on trusted groups and identity schemes is on the
    334  1.1.1.11  christos .Dq Autokey Public\-Key Authentication
    335  1.1.1.11  christos page.
    336       1.1  christos .Pp
    337  1.1.1.11  christos File names begin with the prefix
    338  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey Ns _
    339  1.1.1.11  christos and end with the suffix
    340  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa _ Ns Ar hostname . Ar filestamp ,
    341  1.1.1.11  christos where
    342  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar hostname
    343  1.1.1.11  christos is the owner name, usually the string returned
    344  1.1.1.11  christos by the Unix
    345  1.1.1.11  christos .Xr hostname 1
    346  1.1.1.11  christos command, and
    347  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar filestamp
    348  1.1.1.11  christos is the NTP seconds when the file was generated, in decimal digits.
    349  1.1.1.11  christos This both guarantees uniqueness and simplifies maintenance
    350  1.1.1.11  christos procedures, since all files can be quickly removed
    351  1.1.1.11  christos by a
    352  1.1.1.11  christos .Ic rm Pa ntpkey\&*
    353  1.1.1.11  christos command or all files generated
    354  1.1.1.11  christos at a specific time can be removed by a
    355  1.1.1.11  christos .Ic rm Pa \&* Ns Ar filestamp
    356       1.1  christos command.
    357  1.1.1.11  christos To further reduce the risk of misconfiguration,
    358  1.1.1.11  christos the first two lines of a file contain the file name
    359  1.1.1.11  christos and generation date and time as comments.
    360  1.1.1.11  christos .Ss Trusted Hosts and Groups
    361       1.1  christos Each cryptographic configuration involves selection of a signature scheme
    362       1.1  christos and identification scheme, called a cryptotype,
    363       1.1  christos as explained in the
    364       1.1  christos .Sx Authentication Options
    365       1.1  christos section of
    366       1.1  christos .Xr ntp.conf 5 .
    367  1.1.1.11  christos The default cryptotype uses
    368  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm RSA
    369  1.1.1.11  christos encryption,
    370  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm MD5
    371  1.1.1.11  christos message digest
    372  1.1.1.11  christos and
    373  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm TC
    374  1.1.1.11  christos identification.
    375       1.1  christos First, configure a NTP subnet including one or more low\-stratum
    376       1.1  christos trusted hosts from which all other hosts derive synchronization
    377       1.1  christos directly or indirectly.
    378       1.1  christos Trusted hosts have trusted certificates;
    379       1.1  christos all other hosts have nontrusted certificates.
    380       1.1  christos These hosts will automatically and dynamically build authoritative
    381       1.1  christos certificate trails to one or more trusted hosts.
    382       1.1  christos A trusted group is the set of all hosts that have, directly or indirectly,
    383       1.1  christos a certificate trail ending at a trusted host.
    384       1.1  christos The trail is defined by static configuration file entries
    385       1.1  christos or dynamic means described on the
    386       1.1  christos .Sx Automatic NTP Configuration Options
    387       1.1  christos section of
    388       1.1  christos .Xr ntp.conf 5 .
    389       1.1  christos .Pp
    390       1.1  christos On each trusted host as root, change to the keys directory.
    391       1.1  christos To insure a fresh fileset, remove all
    392  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey
    393       1.1  christos files.
    394       1.1  christos Then run
    395       1.1  christos .Nm
    396       1.1  christos .Fl T
    397       1.1  christos to generate keys and a trusted certificate.
    398       1.1  christos On all other hosts do the same, but leave off the
    399       1.1  christos .Fl T
    400       1.1  christos flag to generate keys and nontrusted certificates.
    401       1.1  christos When complete, start the NTP daemons beginning at the lowest stratum
    402       1.1  christos and working up the tree.
    403       1.1  christos It may take some time for Autokey to instantiate the certificate trails
    404       1.1  christos throughout the subnet, but setting up the environment is completely automatic.
    405       1.1  christos .Pp
    406       1.1  christos If it is necessary to use a different sign key or different digest/signature
    407       1.1  christos scheme than the default, run
    408       1.1  christos .Nm
    409       1.1  christos with the
    410       1.1  christos .Fl S Ar type
    411       1.1  christos option, where
    412       1.1  christos .Ar type
    413       1.1  christos is either
    414       1.1  christos .Cm RSA
    415       1.1  christos or
    416       1.1  christos .Cm DSA .
    417  1.1.1.11  christos The most frequent need to do this is when a
    418  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm DSA Ns \-signed
    419  1.1.1.11  christos certificate is used.
    420       1.1  christos If it is necessary to use a different certificate scheme than the default,
    421       1.1  christos run
    422       1.1  christos .Nm
    423       1.1  christos with the
    424       1.1  christos .Fl c Ar scheme
    425       1.1  christos option and selected
    426       1.1  christos .Ar scheme
    427       1.1  christos as needed.
    428  1.1.1.11  christos If
    429       1.1  christos .Nm
    430       1.1  christos is run again without these options, it generates a new certificate
    431  1.1.1.11  christos using the same scheme and sign key, and soft link.
    432       1.1  christos .Pp
    433       1.1  christos After setting up the environment it is advisable to update certificates
    434       1.1  christos from time to time, if only to extend the validity interval.
    435       1.1  christos Simply run
    436       1.1  christos .Nm
    437       1.1  christos with the same flags as before to generate new certificates
    438  1.1.1.11  christos using existing keys, and soft links.
    439       1.1  christos However, if the host or sign key is changed,
    440       1.1  christos .Xr ntpd 1ntpdmdoc
    441       1.1  christos should be restarted.
    442       1.1  christos When
    443       1.1  christos .Xr ntpd 1ntpdmdoc
    444       1.1  christos is restarted, it loads any new files and restarts the protocol.
    445       1.1  christos Other dependent hosts will continue as usual until signatures are refreshed,
    446       1.1  christos at which time the protocol is restarted.
    447       1.1  christos .Ss Identity Schemes
    448       1.1  christos As mentioned on the Autonomous Authentication page,
    449  1.1.1.11  christos the default
    450  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm TC
    451  1.1.1.11  christos identity scheme is vulnerable to a middleman attack.
    452       1.1  christos However, there are more secure identity schemes available,
    453  1.1.1.11  christos including
    454  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm PC , IFF , GQ
    455  1.1.1.11  christos and
    456  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm MV
    457  1.1.1.11  christos schemes described below.
    458       1.1  christos These schemes are based on a TA, one or more trusted hosts
    459       1.1  christos and some number of nontrusted hosts.
    460       1.1  christos Trusted hosts prove identity using values provided by the TA,
    461       1.1  christos while the remaining hosts prove identity using values provided
    462       1.1  christos by a trusted host and certificate trails that end on that host.
    463       1.1  christos The name of a trusted host is also the name of its sugroup
    464       1.1  christos and also the subject and issuer name on its trusted certificate.
    465       1.1  christos The TA is not necessarily a trusted host in this sense, but often is.
    466       1.1  christos .Pp
    467       1.1  christos In some schemes there are separate keys for servers and clients.
    468       1.1  christos A server can also be a client of another server,
    469       1.1  christos but a client can never be a server for another client.
    470       1.1  christos In general, trusted hosts and nontrusted hosts that operate
    471       1.1  christos as both server and client have parameter files that contain
    472       1.1  christos both server and client keys.
    473       1.1  christos Hosts that operate
    474       1.1  christos only as clients have key files that contain only client keys.
    475       1.1  christos .Pp
    476       1.1  christos The PC scheme supports only one trusted host in the group.
    477       1.1  christos On trusted host alice run
    478       1.1  christos .Nm
    479       1.1  christos .Fl P
    480       1.1  christos .Fl p Ar password
    481       1.1  christos to generate the host key file
    482  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey Ns _ Cm RSA Pa key_alice. Ar filestamp
    483       1.1  christos and trusted private certificate file
    484  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey Ns _ Cm RSA\-MD5 _ Pa cert_alice. Ar filestamp ,
    485  1.1.1.11  christos and soft links.
    486       1.1  christos Copy both files to all group hosts;
    487       1.1  christos they replace the files which would be generated in other schemes.
    488  1.1.1.11  christos On each host
    489  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar bob
    490  1.1.1.11  christos install a soft link from the generic name
    491       1.1  christos .Pa ntpkey_host_ Ns Ar bob
    492       1.1  christos to the host key file and soft link
    493       1.1  christos .Pa ntpkey_cert_ Ns Ar bob
    494       1.1  christos to the private certificate file.
    495       1.1  christos Note the generic links are on bob, but point to files generated
    496       1.1  christos by trusted host alice.
    497       1.1  christos In this scheme it is not possible to refresh
    498       1.1  christos either the keys or certificates without copying them
    499  1.1.1.11  christos to all other hosts in the group, and recreating the soft links.
    500       1.1  christos .Pp
    501  1.1.1.11  christos For the
    502  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm IFF
    503  1.1.1.11  christos scheme proceed as in the
    504  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm TC
    505  1.1.1.11  christos scheme to generate keys
    506       1.1  christos and certificates for all group hosts, then for every trusted host in the group,
    507  1.1.1.11  christos generate the
    508  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm IFF
    509  1.1.1.11  christos parameter file.
    510       1.1  christos On trusted host alice run
    511       1.1  christos .Nm
    512       1.1  christos .Fl T
    513       1.1  christos .Fl I
    514       1.1  christos .Fl p Ar password
    515       1.1  christos to produce her parameter file
    516  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey_IFFpar_alice. Ns Ar filestamp ,
    517       1.1  christos which includes both server and client keys.
    518       1.1  christos Copy this file to all group hosts that operate as both servers
    519       1.1  christos and clients and install a soft link from the generic
    520  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey_iff_alice
    521       1.1  christos to this file.
    522       1.1  christos If there are no hosts restricted to operate only as clients,
    523       1.1  christos there is nothing further to do.
    524  1.1.1.11  christos As the
    525  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm IFF
    526  1.1.1.11  christos scheme is independent
    527       1.1  christos of keys and certificates, these files can be refreshed as needed.
    528       1.1  christos .Pp
    529       1.1  christos If a rogue client has the parameter file, it could masquerade
    530       1.1  christos as a legitimate server and present a middleman threat.
    531       1.1  christos To eliminate this threat, the client keys can be extracted
    532       1.1  christos from the parameter file and distributed to all restricted clients.
    533       1.1  christos After generating the parameter file, on alice run
    534       1.1  christos .Nm
    535       1.1  christos .Fl e
    536  1.1.1.11  christos and pipe the output to a file or email program.
    537  1.1.1.11  christos Copy or email this file to all restricted clients.
    538       1.1  christos On these clients install a soft link from the generic
    539  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey_iff_alice
    540       1.1  christos to this file.
    541       1.1  christos To further protect the integrity of the keys,
    542       1.1  christos each file can be encrypted with a secret password.
    543       1.1  christos .Pp
    544  1.1.1.11  christos For the
    545  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm GQ
    546  1.1.1.11  christos scheme proceed as in the
    547  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm TC
    548  1.1.1.11  christos scheme to generate keys
    549       1.1  christos and certificates for all group hosts, then for every trusted host
    550  1.1.1.11  christos in the group, generate the
    551  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm IFF
    552  1.1.1.11  christos parameter file.
    553       1.1  christos On trusted host alice run
    554       1.1  christos .Nm
    555       1.1  christos .Fl T
    556       1.1  christos .Fl G
    557       1.1  christos .Fl p Ar password
    558       1.1  christos to produce her parameter file
    559  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey_GQpar_alice. Ns Ar filestamp ,
    560       1.1  christos which includes both server and client keys.
    561       1.1  christos Copy this file to all group hosts and install a soft link
    562       1.1  christos from the generic
    563  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey_gq_alice
    564       1.1  christos to this file.
    565  1.1.1.11  christos In addition, on each host
    566  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar bob
    567  1.1.1.11  christos install a soft link
    568       1.1  christos from generic
    569       1.1  christos .Pa ntpkey_gq_ Ns Ar bob
    570       1.1  christos to this file.
    571  1.1.1.11  christos As the
    572  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm GQ
    573  1.1.1.11  christos scheme updates the
    574  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm GQ
    575  1.1.1.11  christos parameters file and certificate
    576       1.1  christos at the same time, keys and certificates can be regenerated as needed.
    577       1.1  christos .Pp
    578  1.1.1.11  christos For the
    579  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm MV
    580  1.1.1.11  christos scheme, proceed as in the
    581  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm TC
    582  1.1.1.11  christos scheme to generate keys
    583       1.1  christos and certificates for all group hosts.
    584       1.1  christos For illustration assume trish is the TA, alice one of several trusted hosts
    585       1.1  christos and bob one of her clients.
    586       1.1  christos On TA trish run
    587       1.1  christos .Nm
    588       1.1  christos .Fl V Ar n
    589       1.1  christos .Fl p Ar password ,
    590       1.1  christos where
    591       1.1  christos .Ar n
    592       1.1  christos is the number of revokable keys (typically 5) to produce
    593       1.1  christos the parameter file
    594  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkeys_MVpar_trish. Ns Ar filestamp
    595       1.1  christos and client key files
    596  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkeys_MVkey Ns Ar d _ Pa trish. Ar filestamp
    597       1.1  christos where
    598       1.1  christos .Ar d
    599       1.1  christos is the key number (0 \&<
    600       1.1  christos .Ar d
    601       1.1  christos \&<
    602       1.1  christos .Ar n ) .
    603       1.1  christos Copy the parameter file to alice and install a soft link
    604       1.1  christos from the generic
    605  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey_mv_alice
    606       1.1  christos to this file.
    607       1.1  christos Copy one of the client key files to alice for later distribution
    608       1.1  christos to her clients.
    609  1.1.1.11  christos It does not matter which client key file goes to alice,
    610       1.1  christos since they all work the same way.
    611  1.1.1.11  christos Alice copies the client key file to all of her clients.
    612       1.1  christos On client bob install a soft link from generic
    613  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey_mvkey_bob
    614       1.1  christos to the client key file.
    615  1.1.1.11  christos As the
    616  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm MV
    617  1.1.1.11  christos scheme is independent of keys and certificates,
    618       1.1  christos these files can be refreshed as needed.
    619       1.1  christos .Ss Command Line Options
    620       1.1  christos .Bl -tag -width indent
    621  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl b Fl \-imbits Ns = Ar modulus
    622  1.1.1.11  christos Set the number of bits in the identity modulus for generating identity keys to
    623  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar modulus
    624  1.1.1.11  christos bits.
    625  1.1.1.11  christos The number of bits in the identity modulus defaults to 256, but can be set to
    626  1.1.1.11  christos values from 256 to 2048 (32 to 256 octets).
    627  1.1.1.11  christos Use the larger moduli with caution, as this can consume considerable computing
    628  1.1.1.11  christos resources and increases the size of authenticated packets.
    629  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl c Fl \-certificate Ns = Ar scheme
    630  1.1.1.11  christos Select certificate signature encryption/message digest scheme.
    631       1.1  christos The
    632       1.1  christos .Ar scheme
    633       1.1  christos can be one of the following:
    634  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm RSA\-MD2 , RSA\-MD5 , RSA\-MDC2 , RSA\-SHA , RSA\-SHA1 , RSA\-RIPEMD160 , DSA\-SHA ,
    635       1.1  christos or
    636       1.1  christos .Cm DSA\-SHA1 .
    637  1.1.1.11  christos Note that
    638  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm RSA
    639  1.1.1.11  christos schemes must be used with an
    640  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm RSA
    641  1.1.1.11  christos sign key and
    642  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm DSA
    643  1.1.1.11  christos schemes must be used with a
    644  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm DSA
    645  1.1.1.11  christos sign key.
    646       1.1  christos The default without this option is
    647       1.1  christos .Cm RSA\-MD5 .
    648  1.1.1.11  christos If compatibility with FIPS 140\-2 is required, either the
    649  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm DSA\-SHA
    650  1.1.1.11  christos or
    651  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm DSA\-SHA1
    652  1.1.1.11  christos scheme must be used.
    653  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl C Fl \-cipher Ns = Ar cipher
    654  1.1.1.11  christos Select the OpenSSL cipher to encrypt the files containing private keys.
    655  1.1.1.11  christos The default without this option is three\-key triple DES in CBC mode,
    656  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm des\-ede3\-cbc .
    657  1.1.1.11  christos The
    658  1.1.1.11  christos .Ic openssl Fl h
    659  1.1.1.11  christos command provided with OpenSSL displays available ciphers.
    660  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl d Fl \-debug\-level
    661  1.1.1.11  christos Increase debugging verbosity level.
    662       1.1  christos This option displays the cryptographic data produced in eye\-friendly billboards.
    663  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl D Fl \-set\-debug\-level Ns = Ar level
    664  1.1.1.11  christos Set the debugging verbosity to
    665  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar level .
    666  1.1.1.11  christos This option displays the cryptographic data produced in eye\-friendly billboards.
    667  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl e Fl \-id\-key
    668  1.1.1.11  christos Write the
    669  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm IFF
    670  1.1.1.11  christos or
    671  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm GQ
    672  1.1.1.11  christos public parameters from the
    673  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar IFFkey or GQkey
    674  1.1.1.11  christos client keys file previously specified
    675  1.1.1.11  christos as unencrypted data to the standard output stream
    676  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa stdout .
    677  1.1.1.11  christos This is intended for automatic key distribution by email.
    678  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl G Fl \-gq\-params
    679  1.1.1.11  christos Generate a new encrypted
    680  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm GQ
    681  1.1.1.11  christos parameters and key file for the Guillou\-Quisquater (GQ) identity scheme.
    682  1.1.1.11  christos This option is mutually exclusive with the
    683  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl I
    684  1.1.1.11  christos and
    685  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl V
    686  1.1.1.11  christos options.
    687  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl H Fl \-host\-key
    688  1.1.1.11  christos Generate a new encrypted
    689  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm RSA
    690  1.1.1.11  christos public/private host key file.
    691  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl I Fl \-iffkey
    692  1.1.1.11  christos Generate a new encrypted
    693  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm IFF
    694  1.1.1.11  christos key file for the Schnorr (IFF) identity scheme.
    695  1.1.1.11  christos This option is mutually exclusive with the
    696  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl G
    697  1.1.1.11  christos and
    698  1.1.1.11  christos Fl V
    699  1.1.1.11  christos options.
    700  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl i Fl \-ident Ns = Ar group
    701  1.1.1.11  christos Set the optional Autokey group name to
    702  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar group .
    703  1.1.1.11  christos This is used in the identity scheme parameter file names of
    704  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm IFF , GQ ,
    705  1.1.1.11  christos and
    706  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm MV
    707  1.1.1.11  christos client parameters files.
    708  1.1.1.11  christos In that role, the default is the host name if no group is provided.
    709  1.1.1.11  christos The group name, if specified using
    710  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl i
    711  1.1.1.11  christos or
    712  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl s
    713  1.1.1.11  christos following an
    714  1.1.1.11  christos .Ql @
    715  1.1.1.11  christos character, is also used in certificate subject and issuer names in the form
    716  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar host @ group
    717  1.1.1.11  christos and should match the group specified via
    718  1.1.1.11  christos .Ic crypto Cm ident
    719  1.1.1.11  christos or
    720  1.1.1.11  christos .Ic server Cm ident
    721  1.1.1.11  christos in the ntpd configuration file.
    722  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl l Fl \-lifetime Ns = Ar days
    723  1.1.1.11  christos Set the lifetime for certificate expiration to
    724  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar days .
    725  1.1.1.11  christos The default lifetime is one year (365 days).
    726  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl m Fl \-modulus Ns = Ar bits
    727  1.1.1.11  christos Set the number of bits in the prime modulus for generating files to
    728  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar bits .
    729  1.1.1.11  christos The modulus defaults to 512, but can be set from 256 to 2048 (32 to 256 octets).
    730  1.1.1.11  christos Use the larger moduli with caution, as this can consume considerable computing
    731  1.1.1.11  christos resources and increases the size of authenticated packets.
    732  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl M Fl \-md5key
    733  1.1.1.11  christos Generate a new symmetric keys file containing 10
    734  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm MD5
    735  1.1.1.11  christos keys, and if OpenSSL is available, 10
    736  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm SHA
    737  1.1.1.11  christos keys.
    738  1.1.1.11  christos An
    739  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm MD5
    740  1.1.1.11  christos key is a string of 20 random printable ASCII characters, while a
    741  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm SHA
    742  1.1.1.11  christos key is a string of 40 random hex digits.
    743  1.1.1.11  christos The file can be edited using a text editor to change the key type or key content.
    744  1.1.1.11  christos This option is mutually exclusive with all other options.
    745  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl p Fl \-password Ns = Ar passwd
    746  1.1.1.11  christos Set the password for reading and writing encrypted files to
    747  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar passwd .
    748  1.1.1.11  christos These include the host, sign and identify key files.
    749  1.1.1.11  christos By default, the password is the string returned by the Unix
    750  1.1.1.11  christos .Ic hostname
    751  1.1.1.11  christos command.
    752  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl P Fl \-pvt\-cert
    753  1.1.1.11  christos Generate a new private certificate used by the
    754  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm PC
    755  1.1.1.11  christos identity scheme.
    756       1.1  christos By default, the program generates public certificates.
    757  1.1.1.11  christos Note: the PC identity scheme is not recommended for new installations.
    758  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl q Fl \-export\-passwd Ns = Ar passwd
    759  1.1.1.11  christos Set the password for writing encrypted
    760  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm IFF , GQ and MV
    761  1.1.1.11  christos identity files redirected to
    762  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa stdout
    763  1.1.1.11  christos to
    764  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar passwd .
    765  1.1.1.11  christos In effect, these files are decrypted with the
    766  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl p
    767  1.1.1.11  christos password, then encrypted with the
    768  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl q
    769  1.1.1.11  christos password.
    770  1.1.1.11  christos By default, the password is the string returned by the Unix
    771  1.1.1.11  christos .Ic hostname
    772  1.1.1.11  christos command.
    773  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl s Fl \-subject\-key Ns = Ar Oo host Oc Op @ Ar group
    774  1.1.1.11  christos Specify the Autokey host name, where
    775  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar host
    776  1.1.1.11  christos is the optional host name and
    777  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar group
    778  1.1.1.11  christos is the optional group name.
    779  1.1.1.11  christos The host name, and if provided, group name are used in
    780  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar host @ group
    781  1.1.1.11  christos form as certificate subject and issuer.
    782  1.1.1.11  christos Specifying
    783  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl s @ Ar group
    784  1.1.1.11  christos is allowed, and results in leaving the host name unchanged, as with
    785  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl i Ar group .
    786  1.1.1.11  christos The group name, or if no group is provided, the host name are also used in the
    787  1.1.1.11  christos file names of
    788  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm IFF , GQ ,
    789  1.1.1.11  christos and
    790  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm MV
    791  1.1.1.11  christos identity scheme client parameter files.
    792  1.1.1.11  christos If
    793  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar host
    794  1.1.1.11  christos is not specified, the default host name is the string returned by the Unix
    795  1.1.1.11  christos .Ic hostname
    796  1.1.1.11  christos command.
    797  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl S Fl \-sign\-key Ns = Op Cm RSA | DSA
    798  1.1.1.11  christos Generate a new encrypted public/private sign key file of the specified type.
    799  1.1.1.11  christos By default, the sign key is the host key and has the same type.
    800  1.1.1.11  christos If compatibility with FIPS 140\-2 is required, the sign key type must be
    801  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm DSA .
    802  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl T Fl \-trusted\-cert
    803       1.1  christos Generate a trusted certificate.
    804       1.1  christos By default, the program generates a non\-trusted certificate.
    805  1.1.1.11  christos .It Fl V Fl \-mv\-params Ar nkeys
    806  1.1.1.11  christos Generate
    807  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar nkeys
    808  1.1.1.11  christos encrypted server keys and parameters for the Mu\-Varadharajan (MV)
    809  1.1.1.11  christos identity scheme.
    810  1.1.1.11  christos This option is mutually exclusive with the
    811  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl I
    812  1.1.1.11  christos and
    813  1.1.1.11  christos .Fl G
    814  1.1.1.11  christos options.
    815  1.1.1.11  christos Note: support for this option should be considered a work in progress.
    816       1.1  christos .El
    817       1.1  christos .Ss Random Seed File
    818       1.1  christos All cryptographically sound key generation schemes must have means
    819       1.1  christos to randomize the entropy seed used to initialize
    820       1.1  christos the internal pseudo\-random number generator used
    821       1.1  christos by the library routines.
    822       1.1  christos The OpenSSL library uses a designated random seed file for this purpose.
    823       1.1  christos The file must be available when starting the NTP daemon and
    824       1.1  christos .Nm
    825       1.1  christos program.
    826       1.1  christos If a site supports OpenSSL or its companion OpenSSH,
    827       1.1  christos it is very likely that means to do this are already available.
    828       1.1  christos .Pp
    829       1.1  christos It is important to understand that entropy must be evolved
    830       1.1  christos for each generation, for otherwise the random number sequence
    831       1.1  christos would be predictable.
    832       1.1  christos Various means dependent on external events, such as keystroke intervals,
    833       1.1  christos can be used to do this and some systems have built\-in entropy sources.
    834       1.1  christos Suitable means are described in the OpenSSL software documentation,
    835       1.1  christos but are outside the scope of this page.
    836       1.1  christos .Pp
    837       1.1  christos The entropy seed used by the OpenSSL library is contained in a file,
    838       1.1  christos usually called
    839  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa .rnd ,
    840       1.1  christos which must be available when starting the NTP daemon
    841       1.1  christos or the
    842       1.1  christos .Nm
    843       1.1  christos program.
    844       1.1  christos The NTP daemon will first look for the file
    845       1.1  christos using the path specified by the
    846  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm randfile
    847       1.1  christos subcommand of the
    848       1.1  christos .Ic crypto
    849       1.1  christos configuration command.
    850       1.1  christos If not specified in this way, or when starting the
    851       1.1  christos .Nm
    852       1.1  christos program,
    853       1.1  christos the OpenSSL library will look for the file using the path specified
    854       1.1  christos by the
    855       1.1  christos .Ev RANDFILE
    856       1.1  christos environment variable in the user home directory,
    857       1.1  christos whether root or some other user.
    858       1.1  christos If the
    859       1.1  christos .Ev RANDFILE
    860       1.1  christos environment variable is not present,
    861       1.1  christos the library will look for the
    862  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa .rnd
    863       1.1  christos file in the user home directory.
    864  1.1.1.11  christos Since both the
    865  1.1.1.11  christos .Nm
    866  1.1.1.11  christos program and
    867  1.1.1.11  christos .Xr ntpd 1ntpdmdoc
    868  1.1.1.11  christos daemon must run as root, the logical place to put this file is in
    869  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa /.rnd
    870  1.1.1.11  christos or
    871  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa /root/.rnd .
    872       1.1  christos If the file is not available or cannot be written,
    873       1.1  christos the daemon exits with a message to the system log and the program
    874       1.1  christos exits with a suitable error message.
    875       1.1  christos .Ss Cryptographic Data Files
    876  1.1.1.11  christos All file formats begin with two nonencrypted lines.
    877  1.1.1.11  christos The first line contains the file name, including the generated host name
    878  1.1.1.11  christos and filestamp, in the format
    879  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey_ Ns Ar key _ Ar name . Ar filestamp ,
    880  1.1.1.11  christos where
    881  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar key
    882  1.1.1.11  christos is the key or parameter type,
    883  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar name
    884  1.1.1.11  christos is the host or group name and
    885  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar filestamp
    886  1.1.1.11  christos is the filestamp (NTP seconds) when the file was created.
    887  1.1.1.11  christos By convention,
    888  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar key
    889  1.1.1.11  christos names in generated file names include both upper and lower case
    890  1.1.1.11  christos characters, while
    891  1.1.1.11  christos .Ar key
    892  1.1.1.11  christos names in generated link names include only lower case characters.
    893  1.1.1.11  christos The filestamp is not used in generated link names.
    894  1.1.1.11  christos The second line contains the datestamp in conventional Unix
    895  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa date
    896  1.1.1.11  christos format.
    897  1.1.1.11  christos Lines beginning with
    898  1.1.1.11  christos .Ql #
    899  1.1.1.11  christos are considered comments and ignored by the
    900       1.1  christos .Nm
    901       1.1  christos program and
    902       1.1  christos .Xr ntpd 1ntpdmdoc
    903       1.1  christos daemon.
    904  1.1.1.11  christos .Pp
    905  1.1.1.11  christos The remainder of the file contains cryptographic data, encoded first using ASN.1
    906  1.1.1.11  christos rules, then encrypted if necessary, and finally written in PEM\-encoded
    907  1.1.1.11  christos printable ASCII text, preceded and followed by MIME content identifier lines.
    908  1.1.1.11  christos .Pp
    909  1.1.1.11  christos The format of the symmetric keys file, ordinarily named
    910  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntp.keys ,
    911  1.1.1.11  christos is somewhat different than the other files in the interest of backward compatibility.
    912  1.1.1.11  christos Ordinarily, the file is generated by this program, but it can be constructed
    913  1.1.1.11  christos and edited using an ordinary text editor.
    914  1.1.1.11  christos .Bd -literal -unfilled -offset center
    915  1.1.1.11  christos # ntpkey_MD5key_bk.ntp.org.3595864945
    916  1.1.1.11  christos # Thu Dec 12 19:22:25 2013
    917  1.1.1.11  christos 1  MD5 L";Nw<\`.I<f4U0)247"i  # MD5 key
    918  1.1.1.11  christos 2  MD5 &>l0%XXK9O'51VwV<xq~  # MD5 key
    919  1.1.1.11  christos 3  MD5 lb4zLW~d^!K:]RsD'qb6  # MD5 key
    920  1.1.1.11  christos 4  MD5 Yue:tL[+vR)M\`n~bY,'?  # MD5 key
    921  1.1.1.11  christos 5  MD5 B;fx'Kgr/&4ZTbL6=RxA  # MD5 key
    922  1.1.1.11  christos 6  MD5 4eYwa\`o}3i@@V (a] ..R9!l  # MD5 key
    923  1.1.1.11  christos 7  MD5 \`A.([h+;wTQ|xfi%Sn_!  # MD5 key
    924  1.1.1.11  christos 8  MD5 45:V,r4]l6y^JH6"Sh?F  # MD5 key
    925  1.1.1.11  christos 9  MD5 3\-5vcn*6l29DS?Xdsg)*  # MD5 key
    926  1.1.1.11  christos 10 MD5 2late4Me              # MD5 key
    927  1.1.1.11  christos 11 SHA1 a27872d3030a9025b8446c751b4551a7629af65c  # SHA1 key
    928  1.1.1.11  christos 12 SHA1 21bc3b4865dbb9e920902abdccb3e04ff97a5e74  # SHA1 key
    929  1.1.1.11  christos 13 SHA1 2b7736fe24fef5ba85ae11594132ab5d6f6daba9  # SHA1 key
    930  1.1.1.11  christos 14 SHA  a5332809c8878dd3a5b918819108a111509aeceb  # SHA  key
    931  1.1.1.11  christos 15 MD2  2fe16c88c760ff2f16d4267e36c1aa6c926e6964  # MD2  key
    932  1.1.1.11  christos 16 MD4  b2691811dc19cfc0e2f9bcacd74213f29812183d  # MD4  key
    933  1.1.1.11  christos 17 MD5  e4d6735b8bdad58ec5ffcb087300a17f7fef1f7c  # MD5  key
    934  1.1.1.11  christos 18 MDC2 a8d5e2315c025bf3a79174c87fbd10477de2eabc  # MDC2 key
    935  1.1.1.11  christos 19 RIPEMD160 77ca332cafb30e3cafb174dcd5b80ded7ba9b3d2  # RIPEMD160 key
    936  1.1.1.11  christos 20 AES128CMAC f92ff73eee86c1e7dc638d6489a04e4e555af878  # AES128CMAC key
    937  1.1.1.11  christos .Ed
    938  1.1.1.11  christos .D1 Figure 1. Typical Symmetric Key File
    939  1.1.1.11  christos .Pp
    940  1.1.1.11  christos Figure 1 shows a typical symmetric keys file used by the reference
    941  1.1.1.11  christos implementation.
    942  1.1.1.11  christos Following the header the keys are entered one per line in the format
    943  1.1.1.11  christos .D1 Ar keyno Ar type Ar key
    944       1.1  christos where
    945       1.1  christos .Ar keyno
    946  1.1.1.12  christos is a positive integer in the range 1\-65535;
    947       1.1  christos .Ar type
    948  1.1.1.11  christos is the key type for the message digest algorithm, which in the absence of the
    949  1.1.1.11  christos OpenSSL library must be
    950  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm MD5
    951  1.1.1.11  christos to designate the MD5 message digest algorithm;
    952  1.1.1.11  christos if the OpenSSL library is installed, the key type can be any
    953  1.1.1.11  christos message digest algorithm supported by that library;
    954  1.1.1.11  christos however, if compatibility with FIPS 140\-2 is required,
    955  1.1.1.11  christos the key type must be either
    956  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm SHA
    957  1.1.1.11  christos or
    958  1.1.1.11  christos .Cm SHA1 ;
    959       1.1  christos .Ar key
    960       1.1  christos is the key itself,
    961  1.1.1.11  christos which is a printable ASCII string 20 characters or less in length:
    962  1.1.1.11  christos each character is chosen from the 93 printable characters
    963  1.1.1.11  christos in the range 0x21 through 0x7e (
    964  1.1.1.11  christos .Ql !
    965  1.1.1.11  christos through
    966  1.1.1.11  christos .Ql ~
    967  1.1.1.11  christos \&) excluding space and the
    968  1.1.1.11  christos .Ql #
    969  1.1.1.11  christos character, and terminated by whitespace or a
    970       1.1  christos .Ql #
    971       1.1  christos character.
    972  1.1.1.11  christos An OpenSSL key consists of a hex\-encoded ASCII string of 40 characters, which
    973  1.1.1.11  christos is truncated as necessary.
    974       1.1  christos .Pp
    975       1.1  christos Note that the keys used by the
    976       1.1  christos .Xr ntpq 1ntpqmdoc
    977       1.1  christos and
    978       1.1  christos .Xr ntpdc 1ntpdcmdoc
    979       1.1  christos programs
    980       1.1  christos are checked against passwords requested by the programs
    981       1.1  christos and entered by hand, so it is generally appropriate to specify these keys
    982       1.1  christos in human readable ASCII format.
    983       1.1  christos .Pp
    984       1.1  christos The
    985       1.1  christos .Nm
    986  1.1.1.11  christos program generates a symmetric keys file
    987  1.1.1.11  christos .Pa ntpkey_MD5key_ Ns Ar hostname Ns . Ns Ar filestamp .
    988       1.1  christos Since the file contains private shared keys,
    989       1.1  christos it should be visible only to root and distributed by secure means
    990       1.1  christos to other subnet hosts.
    991       1.1  christos The NTP daemon loads the file
    992       1.1  christos .Pa ntp.keys ,
    993       1.1  christos so
    994       1.1  christos .Nm
    995       1.1  christos installs a soft link from this name to the generated file.
    996       1.1  christos Subsequently, similar soft links must be installed by manual
    997       1.1  christos or automated means on the other subnet hosts.
    998       1.1  christos While this file is not used with the Autokey Version 2 protocol,
    999       1.1  christos it is needed to authenticate some remote configuration commands
   1000       1.1  christos used by the
   1001       1.1  christos .Xr ntpq 1ntpqmdoc
   1002       1.1  christos and
   1003       1.1  christos .Xr ntpdc 1ntpdcmdoc
   1004       1.1  christos utilities.
   1005       1.1  christos .Sh "OPTIONS"
   1006       1.1  christos .Bl -tag
   1007       1.1  christos .It  Fl b Ar imbits , Fl \-imbits Ns = Ns Ar imbits 
   1008       1.1  christos identity modulus bits.
   1009       1.1  christos This option takes an integer number as its argument.
   1010       1.1  christos The value of
   1011       1.1  christos .Ar imbits
   1012       1.1  christos is constrained to being:
   1013       1.1  christos .in +4
   1014       1.1  christos .nf
   1015       1.1  christos .na
   1016       1.1  christos in the range  256 through 2048
   1017       1.1  christos .fi
   1018       1.1  christos .in -4
   1019       1.1  christos .sp
   1020  1.1.1.15  christos The number of bits in the identity modulus.  The default is 512.
   1021       1.1  christos .It  Fl c Ar scheme , Fl \-certificate Ns = Ns Ar scheme 
   1022       1.1  christos certificate scheme.
   1023       1.1  christos .sp
   1024       1.1  christos scheme is one of
   1025  1.1.1.11  christos RSA\-MD2, RSA\-MD5, RSA\-MDC2, RSA\-SHA, RSA\-SHA1, RSA\-RIPEMD160,
   1026       1.1  christos DSA\-SHA, or DSA\-SHA1.
   1027       1.1  christos .sp
   1028  1.1.1.11  christos Select the certificate signature encryption/message digest scheme.
   1029       1.1  christos Note that RSA schemes must be used with a RSA sign key and DSA
   1030       1.1  christos schemes must be used with a DSA sign key.  The default without
   1031       1.1  christos this option is RSA\-MD5.
   1032       1.1  christos .It  Fl C Ar cipher , Fl \-cipher Ns = Ns Ar cipher 
   1033       1.1  christos privatekey cipher.
   1034       1.1  christos .sp
   1035       1.1  christos Select the cipher which is used to encrypt the files containing
   1036       1.1  christos private keys.  The default is three\-key triple DES in CBC mode,
   1037  1.1.1.11  christos equivalent to "\fB\-C des\-ede3\-cbc\fP".  The openssl tool lists ciphers
   1038       1.1  christos available in "\fBopenssl \-h\fP" output.
   1039       1.1  christos .It  Fl d , Fl \-debug\-level 
   1040       1.1  christos Increase debug verbosity level.
   1041       1.1  christos This option may appear an unlimited number of times.
   1042       1.1  christos .sp
   1043       1.1  christos .It  Fl D Ar number , Fl \-set\-debug\-level Ns = Ns Ar number 
   1044       1.1  christos Set the debug verbosity level.
   1045       1.1  christos This option may appear an unlimited number of times.
   1046       1.1  christos This option takes an integer number as its argument.
   1047       1.1  christos .sp
   1048       1.1  christos .It  Fl e , Fl \-id\-key 
   1049       1.1  christos Write IFF or GQ identity keys.
   1050       1.1  christos .sp
   1051  1.1.1.11  christos Write the public parameters from the IFF or GQ client keys to
   1052  1.1.1.11  christos the standard output.
   1053  1.1.1.11  christos This is intended for automatic key distribution by email.
   1054       1.1  christos .It  Fl G , Fl \-gq\-params 
   1055       1.1  christos Generate GQ parameters and keys.
   1056       1.1  christos .sp
   1057       1.1  christos Generate parameters and keys for the GQ identification scheme,
   1058       1.1  christos obsoleting any that may exist.
   1059       1.1  christos .It  Fl H , Fl \-host\-key 
   1060       1.1  christos generate RSA host key.
   1061       1.1  christos .sp
   1062       1.1  christos Generate new host keys, obsoleting any that may exist.
   1063       1.1  christos .It  Fl I , Fl \-iffkey 
   1064       1.1  christos generate IFF parameters.
   1065       1.1  christos .sp
   1066       1.1  christos Generate parameters for the IFF identification scheme, obsoleting
   1067       1.1  christos any that may exist.
   1068       1.1  christos .It  Fl i Ar group , Fl \-ident Ns = Ns Ar group 
   1069       1.1  christos set Autokey group name.
   1070       1.1  christos .sp
   1071       1.1  christos Set the optional Autokey group name to name.  This is used in
   1072       1.1  christos the file name of IFF, GQ, and MV client parameters files.  In
   1073       1.1  christos that role, the default is the host name if this option is not
   1074       1.1  christos provided.  The group name, if specified using \fB\-i/\-\-ident\fP or
   1075       1.1  christos using \fB\-s/\-\-subject\-name\fP following an '\fB@\fP' character,
   1076  1.1.1.11  christos is also a part of the self\-signed host certificate subject and
   1077       1.1  christos issuer names in the form \fBhost@group\fP and should match the
   1078  1.1.1.11  christos \'\fBcrypto ident\fP' or '\fBserver ident\fP' configuration in the
   1079  1.1.1.11  christos \fBntpd\fP configuration file.
   1080       1.1  christos .It  Fl l Ar lifetime , Fl \-lifetime Ns = Ns Ar lifetime 
   1081       1.1  christos set certificate lifetime.
   1082       1.1  christos This option takes an integer number as its argument.
   1083       1.1  christos .sp
   1084       1.1  christos Set the certificate expiration to lifetime days from now.
   1085       1.1  christos .It  Fl m Ar modulus , Fl \-modulus Ns = Ns Ar modulus 
   1086  1.1.1.11  christos prime modulus.
   1087       1.1  christos This option takes an integer number as its argument.
   1088       1.1  christos The value of
   1089       1.1  christos .Ar modulus
   1090       1.1  christos is constrained to being:
   1091       1.1  christos .in +4
   1092       1.1  christos .nf
   1093       1.1  christos .na
   1094       1.1  christos in the range  256 through 2048
   1095       1.1  christos .fi
   1096       1.1  christos .in -4
   1097       1.1  christos .sp
   1098       1.1  christos The number of bits in the prime modulus.  The default is 512.
   1099  1.1.1.11  christos .It  Fl M , Fl \-md5key 
   1100  1.1.1.11  christos generate symmetric keys.
   1101  1.1.1.11  christos .sp
   1102  1.1.1.11  christos Generate symmetric keys, obsoleting any that may exist.
   1103       1.1  christos .It  Fl P , Fl \-pvt\-cert 
   1104       1.1  christos generate PC private certificate.
   1105       1.1  christos .sp
   1106       1.1  christos Generate a private certificate.  By default, the program generates
   1107       1.1  christos public certificates.
   1108   1.1.1.2  christos .It  Fl p Ar passwd , Fl \-password Ns = Ns Ar passwd 
   1109   1.1.1.2  christos local private password.
   1110       1.1  christos .sp
   1111   1.1.1.2  christos Local files containing private data are encrypted with the
   1112   1.1.1.2  christos DES\-CBC algorithm and the specified password.  The same password
   1113   1.1.1.2  christos must be specified to the local ntpd via the "crypto pw password"
   1114   1.1.1.2  christos configuration command.  The default password is the local
   1115   1.1.1.2  christos hostname.
   1116   1.1.1.2  christos .It  Fl q Ar passwd , Fl \-export\-passwd Ns = Ns Ar passwd 
   1117   1.1.1.2  christos export IFF or GQ group keys with password.
   1118   1.1.1.2  christos .sp
   1119   1.1.1.2  christos Export IFF or GQ identity group keys to the standard output,
   1120   1.1.1.2  christos encrypted with the DES\-CBC algorithm and the specified password.
   1121   1.1.1.2  christos The same password must be specified to the remote ntpd via the
   1122   1.1.1.2  christos "crypto pw password" configuration command.  See also the option
   1123   1.1.1.2  christos -\-id\-key (\-e) for unencrypted exports.
   1124       1.1  christos .It  Fl s Ar host@group , Fl \-subject\-name Ns = Ns Ar host@group 
   1125       1.1  christos set host and optionally group name.
   1126       1.1  christos .sp
   1127       1.1  christos Set the Autokey host name, and optionally, group name specified
   1128       1.1  christos following an '\fB@\fP' character.  The host name is used in the file
   1129       1.1  christos name of generated host and signing certificates, without the
   1130       1.1  christos group name.  The host name, and if provided, group name are used
   1131  1.1.1.11  christos in \fBhost@group\fP form for the host certificate subject and issuer
   1132       1.1  christos fields.  Specifying '\fB\-s @group\fP' is allowed, and results in
   1133       1.1  christos leaving the host name unchanged while appending \fB@group\fP to the
   1134       1.1  christos subject and issuer fields, as with \fB\-i group\fP.  The group name, or
   1135       1.1  christos if not provided, the host name are also used in the file names
   1136       1.1  christos of IFF, GQ, and MV client parameter files.
   1137  1.1.1.11  christos .It  Fl S Ar sign , Fl \-sign\-key Ns = Ns Ar sign 
   1138  1.1.1.11  christos generate sign key (RSA or DSA).
   1139  1.1.1.11  christos .sp
   1140  1.1.1.11  christos Generate a new sign key of the designated type, obsoleting any
   1141  1.1.1.11  christos that may exist.  By default, the program uses the host key as the
   1142  1.1.1.11  christos sign key.
   1143       1.1  christos .It  Fl T , Fl \-trusted\-cert 
   1144       1.1  christos trusted certificate (TC scheme).
   1145       1.1  christos .sp
   1146       1.1  christos Generate a trusted certificate.  By default, the program generates
   1147       1.1  christos a non\-trusted certificate.
   1148       1.1  christos .It  Fl V Ar num , Fl \-mv\-params Ns = Ns Ar num 
   1149       1.1  christos generate <num> MV parameters.
   1150       1.1  christos This option takes an integer number as its argument.
   1151       1.1  christos .sp
   1152       1.1  christos Generate parameters and keys for the Mu\-Varadharajan (MV)
   1153       1.1  christos identification scheme.
   1154       1.1  christos .It  Fl v Ar num , Fl \-mv\-keys Ns = Ns Ar num 
   1155       1.1  christos update <num> MV keys.
   1156       1.1  christos This option takes an integer number as its argument.
   1157       1.1  christos .sp
   1158       1.1  christos This option has not been fully documented.
   1159       1.1  christos .It Fl \&? , Fl \-help
   1160       1.1  christos Display usage information and exit.
   1161       1.1  christos .It Fl \&! , Fl \-more\-help
   1162       1.1  christos Pass the extended usage information through a pager.
   1163       1.1  christos .It Fl > Oo Ar cfgfile Oc , Fl \-save\-opts Oo Ns = Ns Ar cfgfile Oc
   1164       1.1  christos Save the option state to \fIcfgfile\fP.  The default is the \fIlast\fP
   1165       1.1  christos configuration file listed in the \fBOPTION PRESETS\fP section, below.
   1166       1.1  christos The command will exit after updating the config file.
   1167       1.1  christos .It Fl < Ar cfgfile , Fl \-load\-opts Ns = Ns Ar cfgfile , Fl \-no\-load\-opts
   1168       1.1  christos Load options from \fIcfgfile\fP.
   1169       1.1  christos The \fIno\-load\-opts\fP form will disable the loading
   1170       1.1  christos of earlier config/rc/ini files.  \fI\-\-no\-load\-opts\fP is handled early,
   1171       1.1  christos out of order.
   1172       1.1  christos .It Fl \-version Op Brq Ar v|c|n
   1173       1.1  christos Output version of program and exit.  The default mode is `v', a simple
   1174       1.1  christos version.  The `c' mode will print copyright information and `n' will
   1175       1.1  christos print the full copyright notice.
   1176       1.1  christos .El
   1177       1.1  christos .Sh "OPTION PRESETS"
   1178       1.1  christos Any option that is not marked as \fInot presettable\fP may be preset
   1179       1.1  christos by loading values from configuration ("RC" or ".INI") file(s) and values from
   1180       1.1  christos environment variables named:
   1181       1.1  christos .nf
   1182       1.1  christos   \fBNTP_KEYGEN_<option\-name>\fP or \fBNTP_KEYGEN\fP
   1183       1.1  christos .fi
   1184       1.1  christos .ad
   1185       1.1  christos The environmental presets take precedence (are processed later than)
   1186       1.1  christos the configuration files.
   1187       1.1  christos The \fIhomerc\fP files are "\fI$HOME\fP", and "\fI.\fP".
   1188       1.1  christos If any of these are directories, then the file \fI.ntprc\fP
   1189       1.1  christos is searched for within those directories.
   1190       1.1  christos .Sh USAGE
   1191       1.1  christos .Sh "ENVIRONMENT"
   1192       1.1  christos See \fBOPTION PRESETS\fP for configuration environment variables.
   1193       1.1  christos .Sh "FILES"
   1194       1.1  christos See \fBOPTION PRESETS\fP for configuration files.
   1195       1.1  christos .Sh "EXIT STATUS"
   1196       1.1  christos One of the following exit values will be returned:
   1197       1.1  christos .Bl -tag
   1198       1.1  christos .It 0 " (EXIT_SUCCESS)"
   1199       1.1  christos Successful program execution.
   1200       1.1  christos .It 1 " (EXIT_FAILURE)"
   1201       1.1  christos The operation failed or the command syntax was not valid.
   1202       1.1  christos .It 66 " (EX_NOINPUT)"
   1203       1.1  christos A specified configuration file could not be loaded.
   1204       1.1  christos .It 70 " (EX_SOFTWARE)"
   1205       1.1  christos libopts had an internal operational error.  Please report
   1206       1.1  christos it to autogen\-users (a] lists.sourceforge.net.  Thank you.
   1207       1.1  christos .El
   1208       1.1  christos .Sh "AUTHORS"
   1209   1.1.1.3  christos The University of Delaware and Network Time Foundation
   1210       1.1  christos .Sh "COPYRIGHT"
   1211  1.1.1.15  christos Copyright (C) 1992\-2024 The University of Delaware and Network Time Foundation all rights reserved.
   1212       1.1  christos This program is released under the terms of the NTP license, <http://ntp.org/license>.
   1213       1.1  christos .Sh BUGS
   1214  1.1.1.11  christos It can take quite a while to generate some cryptographic values.
   1215       1.1  christos .Pp
   1216       1.1  christos Please report bugs to http://bugs.ntp.org .
   1217       1.1  christos .Pp
   1218  1.1.1.15  christos Please send bug reports to: https://bugs.ntp.org, bugs (a] ntp.org
   1219       1.1  christos .Sh NOTES
   1220       1.1  christos Portions of this document came from FreeBSD.
   1221       1.1  christos .Pp
   1222       1.1  christos This manual page was \fIAutoGen\fP\-erated from the \fBntp\-keygen\fP
   1223       1.1  christos option definitions.
   1224