Home | History | Annotate | Line # | Download | only in libpthread
pthread_tsd.c revision 1.17
      1  1.17  christos /*	$NetBSD: pthread_tsd.c,v 1.17 2019/03/05 01:35:52 christos Exp $	*/
      2   1.1   nathanw 
      3   1.1   nathanw /*-
      4   1.3        ad  * Copyright (c) 2001, 2007 The NetBSD Foundation, Inc.
      5   1.1   nathanw  * All rights reserved.
      6   1.1   nathanw  *
      7   1.1   nathanw  * This code is derived from software contributed to The NetBSD Foundation
      8  1.10  christos  * by Nathan J. Williams, by Andrew Doran, and by Christos Zoulas.
      9   1.1   nathanw  *
     10   1.1   nathanw  * Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without
     11   1.1   nathanw  * modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions
     12   1.1   nathanw  * are met:
     13   1.1   nathanw  * 1. Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright
     14   1.1   nathanw  *    notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer.
     15   1.1   nathanw  * 2. Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright
     16   1.1   nathanw  *    notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in the
     17   1.1   nathanw  *    documentation and/or other materials provided with the distribution.
     18   1.1   nathanw  *
     19   1.1   nathanw  * THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE NETBSD FOUNDATION, INC. AND CONTRIBUTORS
     20   1.1   nathanw  * ``AS IS'' AND ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED
     21   1.1   nathanw  * TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR
     22   1.1   nathanw  * PURPOSE ARE DISCLAIMED.  IN NO EVENT SHALL THE FOUNDATION OR CONTRIBUTORS
     23   1.1   nathanw  * BE LIABLE FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR
     24   1.1   nathanw  * CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PROCUREMENT OF
     25   1.1   nathanw  * SUBSTITUTE GOODS OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, DATA, OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS
     26   1.1   nathanw  * INTERRUPTION) HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN
     27   1.1   nathanw  * CONTRACT, STRICT LIABILITY, OR TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE)
     28   1.1   nathanw  * ARISING IN ANY WAY OUT OF THE USE OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE
     29   1.1   nathanw  * POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGE.
     30   1.1   nathanw  */
     31   1.1   nathanw 
     32   1.1   nathanw #include <sys/cdefs.h>
     33  1.17  christos __RCSID("$NetBSD: pthread_tsd.c,v 1.17 2019/03/05 01:35:52 christos Exp $");
     34   1.1   nathanw 
     35   1.1   nathanw /* Functions and structures dealing with thread-specific data */
     36   1.1   nathanw #include <errno.h>
     37  1.13  christos #include <sys/mman.h>
     38   1.1   nathanw 
     39   1.1   nathanw #include "pthread.h"
     40   1.1   nathanw #include "pthread_int.h"
     41  1.11  christos #include "reentrant.h"
     42  1.17  christos #include "tsd.h"
     43   1.1   nathanw 
     44  1.12      manu int pthread_keys_max;
     45   1.1   nathanw static pthread_mutex_t tsd_mutex = PTHREAD_MUTEX_INITIALIZER;
     46   1.1   nathanw static int nextkey;
     47   1.9  christos 
     48  1.12      manu PTQ_HEAD(pthread__tsd_list, pt_specific) *pthread__tsd_list = NULL;
     49  1.12      manu void (**pthread__tsd_destructors)(void *) = NULL;
     50   1.1   nathanw 
     51   1.1   nathanw __strong_alias(__libc_thr_keycreate,pthread_key_create)
     52   1.1   nathanw __strong_alias(__libc_thr_keydelete,pthread_key_delete)
     53   1.1   nathanw 
     54   1.9  christos static void
     55   1.9  christos /*ARGSUSED*/
     56   1.9  christos null_destructor(void *p)
     57   1.9  christos {
     58   1.9  christos }
     59   1.9  christos 
     60  1.11  christos #include <err.h>
     61  1.11  christos #include <stdlib.h>
     62  1.12      manu #include <stdio.h>
     63  1.12      manu 
     64  1.13  christos void *
     65  1.13  christos pthread_tsd_init(size_t *tlen)
     66  1.12      manu {
     67  1.12      manu 	char *pkm;
     68  1.13  christos 	size_t alen;
     69  1.13  christos 	char *arena;
     70  1.12      manu 
     71  1.13  christos 	if ((pkm = pthread__getenv("PTHREAD_KEYS_MAX")) != NULL) {
     72  1.12      manu 		pthread_keys_max = (int)strtol(pkm, NULL, 0);
     73  1.12      manu 		if (pthread_keys_max < _POSIX_THREAD_KEYS_MAX)
     74  1.12      manu 			pthread_keys_max = _POSIX_THREAD_KEYS_MAX;
     75  1.12      manu 	} else {
     76  1.12      manu 		pthread_keys_max = PTHREAD_KEYS_MAX;
     77  1.12      manu 	}
     78  1.12      manu 
     79  1.13  christos 	/*
     80  1.13  christos 	 * Can't use malloc here yet, because malloc will use the fake
     81  1.13  christos 	 * libc thread functions to initialize itself, so mmap the space.
     82  1.13  christos 	 */
     83  1.13  christos 	*tlen = sizeof(struct __pthread_st)
     84  1.13  christos 	    + pthread_keys_max * sizeof(struct pt_specific);
     85  1.13  christos 	alen = *tlen
     86  1.13  christos 	    + sizeof(*pthread__tsd_list) * pthread_keys_max
     87  1.13  christos 	    + sizeof(*pthread__tsd_destructors) * pthread_keys_max;
     88  1.13  christos 
     89  1.15     pooka 	arena = mmap(NULL, alen, PROT_READ|PROT_WRITE, MAP_ANON, -1, 0);
     90  1.13  christos 	if (arena == MAP_FAILED) {
     91  1.13  christos 		pthread_keys_max = 0;
     92  1.13  christos 		return NULL;
     93  1.13  christos 	}
     94  1.12      manu 
     95  1.13  christos 	pthread__tsd_list = (void *)arena;
     96  1.13  christos 	arena += sizeof(*pthread__tsd_list) * pthread_keys_max;
     97  1.13  christos 	pthread__tsd_destructors = (void *)arena;
     98  1.13  christos 	arena += sizeof(*pthread__tsd_destructors) * pthread_keys_max;
     99  1.13  christos 	return arena;
    100  1.12      manu }
    101  1.12      manu 
    102   1.1   nathanw int
    103   1.1   nathanw pthread_key_create(pthread_key_t *key, void (*destructor)(void *))
    104   1.1   nathanw {
    105   1.1   nathanw 	int i;
    106   1.1   nathanw 
    107  1.11  christos 	if (__predict_false(__uselibcstub))
    108  1.11  christos 		return __libc_thr_keycreate_stub(key, destructor);
    109  1.11  christos 
    110   1.1   nathanw 	/* Get a lock on the allocation list */
    111   1.1   nathanw 	pthread_mutex_lock(&tsd_mutex);
    112   1.1   nathanw 
    113   1.9  christos 	/* Find an available slot:
    114   1.9  christos 	 * The condition for an available slot is one with the destructor
    115   1.9  christos 	 * not being NULL. If the desired destructor is NULL we set it to
    116   1.9  christos 	 * our own internal destructor to satisfy the non NULL condition.
    117   1.9  christos 	 */
    118   1.1   nathanw 	/* 1. Search from "nextkey" to the end of the list. */
    119  1.12      manu 	for (i = nextkey; i < pthread_keys_max; i++)
    120   1.9  christos 		if (pthread__tsd_destructors[i] == NULL)
    121   1.1   nathanw 			break;
    122   1.1   nathanw 
    123  1.12      manu 	if (i == pthread_keys_max) {
    124   1.1   nathanw 		/* 2. If that didn't work, search from the start
    125   1.1   nathanw 		 *    of the list back to "nextkey".
    126   1.1   nathanw 		 */
    127   1.1   nathanw 		for (i = 0; i < nextkey; i++)
    128   1.9  christos 			if (pthread__tsd_destructors[i] == NULL)
    129   1.1   nathanw 				break;
    130   1.1   nathanw 
    131   1.1   nathanw 		if (i == nextkey) {
    132   1.1   nathanw 			/* If we didn't find one here, there isn't one
    133   1.1   nathanw 			 * to be found.
    134   1.1   nathanw 			 */
    135   1.1   nathanw 			pthread_mutex_unlock(&tsd_mutex);
    136   1.1   nathanw 			return EAGAIN;
    137   1.1   nathanw 		}
    138   1.1   nathanw 	}
    139   1.1   nathanw 
    140   1.1   nathanw 	/* Got one. */
    141   1.9  christos 	pthread__assert(PTQ_EMPTY(&pthread__tsd_list[i]));
    142   1.9  christos 	pthread__tsd_destructors[i] = destructor ? destructor : null_destructor;
    143   1.9  christos 
    144  1.12      manu 	nextkey = (i + 1) % pthread_keys_max;
    145   1.1   nathanw 	pthread_mutex_unlock(&tsd_mutex);
    146   1.1   nathanw 	*key = i;
    147   1.1   nathanw 
    148   1.1   nathanw 	return 0;
    149   1.1   nathanw }
    150   1.1   nathanw 
    151   1.9  christos /*
    152  1.12      manu  * Each thread holds an array of pthread_keys_max pt_specific list
    153   1.9  christos  * elements. When an element is used it is inserted into the appropriate
    154   1.9  christos  * key bucket of pthread__tsd_list. This means that ptqe_prev == NULL,
    155   1.9  christos  * means that the element is not threaded, ptqe_prev != NULL it is
    156   1.9  christos  * already part of the list. When we set to a NULL value we delete from the
    157   1.9  christos  * list if it was in the list, and when we set to non-NULL value, we insert
    158   1.9  christos  * in the list if it was not already there.
    159   1.9  christos  *
    160   1.9  christos  * We keep this global array of lists of threads that have called
    161   1.9  christos  * pthread_set_specific with non-null values, for each key so that
    162   1.9  christos  * we don't have to check all threads for non-NULL values in
    163   1.9  christos  * pthread_key_destroy
    164   1.9  christos  *
    165   1.9  christos  * We could keep an accounting of the number of specific used
    166   1.9  christos  * entries per thread, so that we can update pt_havespecific when we delete
    167   1.9  christos  * the last one, but we don't bother for now
    168   1.9  christos  */
    169   1.9  christos int
    170   1.9  christos pthread__add_specific(pthread_t self, pthread_key_t key, const void *value)
    171   1.9  christos {
    172   1.9  christos 	struct pt_specific *pt;
    173   1.9  christos 
    174  1.12      manu 	pthread__assert(key >= 0 && key < pthread_keys_max);
    175   1.9  christos 
    176   1.9  christos 	pthread_mutex_lock(&tsd_mutex);
    177   1.9  christos 	pthread__assert(pthread__tsd_destructors[key] != NULL);
    178   1.9  christos 	pt = &self->pt_specific[key];
    179   1.9  christos 	self->pt_havespecific = 1;
    180   1.9  christos 	if (value) {
    181   1.9  christos 		if (pt->pts_next.ptqe_prev == NULL)
    182   1.9  christos 			PTQ_INSERT_HEAD(&pthread__tsd_list[key], pt, pts_next);
    183   1.9  christos 	} else {
    184   1.9  christos 		if (pt->pts_next.ptqe_prev != NULL) {
    185   1.9  christos 			PTQ_REMOVE(&pthread__tsd_list[key], pt, pts_next);
    186   1.9  christos 			pt->pts_next.ptqe_prev = NULL;
    187   1.9  christos 		}
    188   1.9  christos 	}
    189   1.9  christos 	pt->pts_value = __UNCONST(value);
    190   1.9  christos 	pthread_mutex_unlock(&tsd_mutex);
    191   1.9  christos 
    192   1.9  christos 	return 0;
    193   1.9  christos }
    194   1.9  christos 
    195   1.1   nathanw int
    196   1.1   nathanw pthread_key_delete(pthread_key_t key)
    197   1.1   nathanw {
    198   1.1   nathanw 	/*
    199   1.1   nathanw 	 * This is tricky.  The standard says of pthread_key_create()
    200   1.1   nathanw 	 * that new keys have the value NULL associated with them in
    201   1.1   nathanw 	 * all threads.  According to people who were present at the
    202   1.1   nathanw 	 * standardization meeting, that requirement was written
    203   1.1   nathanw 	 * before pthread_key_delete() was introduced, and not
    204   1.1   nathanw 	 * reconsidered when it was.
    205   1.1   nathanw 	 *
    206   1.1   nathanw 	 * See David Butenhof's article in comp.programming.threads:
    207   1.1   nathanw 	 * Subject: Re: TSD key reusing issue
    208   1.1   nathanw 	 * Message-ID: <u97d8.29$fL6.200 (at) news.cpqcorp.net>
    209   1.1   nathanw 	 * Date: Thu, 21 Feb 2002 09:06:17 -0500
    210  1.10  christos 	 *	 http://groups.google.com/groups?\
    211  1.10  christos 	 *	 hl=en&selm=u97d8.29%24fL6.200%40news.cpqcorp.net
    212   1.1   nathanw 	 *
    213   1.1   nathanw 	 * Given:
    214   1.1   nathanw 	 *
    215   1.1   nathanw 	 * 1: Applications are not required to clear keys in all
    216   1.1   nathanw 	 *    threads before calling pthread_key_delete().
    217   1.1   nathanw 	 * 2: Clearing pointers without running destructors is a
    218   1.1   nathanw 	 *    memory leak.
    219   1.1   nathanw 	 * 3: The pthread_key_delete() function is expressly forbidden
    220   1.1   nathanw 	 *    to run any destructors.
    221   1.1   nathanw 	 *
    222   1.1   nathanw 	 * Option 1: Make this function effectively a no-op and
    223   1.1   nathanw 	 * prohibit key reuse. This is a possible resource-exhaustion
    224   1.1   nathanw 	 * problem given that we have a static storage area for keys,
    225   1.1   nathanw 	 * but having a non-static storage area would make
    226   1.1   nathanw 	 * pthread_setspecific() expensive (might need to realloc the
    227   1.1   nathanw 	 * TSD array).
    228   1.1   nathanw 	 *
    229   1.1   nathanw 	 * Option 2: Ignore the specified behavior of
    230   1.1   nathanw 	 * pthread_key_create() and leave the old values. If an
    231   1.1   nathanw 	 * application deletes a key that still has non-NULL values in
    232   1.1   nathanw 	 * some threads... it's probably a memory leak and hence
    233   1.1   nathanw 	 * incorrect anyway, and we're within our rights to let the
    234   1.1   nathanw 	 * application lose. However, it's possible (if unlikely) that
    235   1.1   nathanw 	 * the application is storing pointers to non-heap data, or
    236   1.1   nathanw 	 * non-pointers that have been wedged into a void pointer, so
    237   1.1   nathanw 	 * we can't entirely write off such applications as incorrect.
    238   1.1   nathanw 	 * This could also lead to running (new) destructors on old
    239   1.1   nathanw 	 * data that was never supposed to be associated with that
    240   1.1   nathanw 	 * destructor.
    241   1.1   nathanw 	 *
    242   1.1   nathanw 	 * Option 3: Follow the specified behavior of
    243   1.1   nathanw 	 * pthread_key_create().  Either pthread_key_create() or
    244   1.1   nathanw 	 * pthread_key_delete() would then have to clear the values in
    245   1.1   nathanw 	 * every thread's slot for that key. In order to guarantee the
    246   1.1   nathanw 	 * visibility of the NULL value in other threads, there would
    247   1.1   nathanw 	 * have to be synchronization operations in both the clearer
    248   1.1   nathanw 	 * and pthread_getspecific().  Putting synchronization in
    249   1.1   nathanw 	 * pthread_getspecific() is a big performance lose.  But in
    250   1.1   nathanw 	 * reality, only (buggy) reuse of an old key would require
    251   1.1   nathanw 	 * this synchronization; for a new key, there has to be a
    252   1.1   nathanw 	 * memory-visibility propagating event between the call to
    253   1.1   nathanw 	 * pthread_key_create() and pthread_getspecific() with that
    254   1.1   nathanw 	 * key, so setting the entries to NULL without synchronization
    255   1.1   nathanw 	 * will work, subject to problem (2) above. However, it's kind
    256   1.1   nathanw 	 * of slow.
    257   1.1   nathanw 	 *
    258   1.1   nathanw 	 * Note that the argument in option 3 only applies because we
    259   1.1   nathanw 	 * keep TSD in ordinary memory which follows the pthreads
    260   1.1   nathanw 	 * visibility rules. The visibility rules are not required by
    261   1.1   nathanw 	 * the standard to apply to TSD, so the argument doesn't
    262   1.1   nathanw 	 * apply in general, just to this implementation.
    263   1.1   nathanw 	 */
    264   1.1   nathanw 
    265   1.9  christos 	/*
    266   1.9  christos 	 * We do option 3; we find the list of all pt_specific structures
    267  1.10  christos 	 * threaded on the key we are deleting, unthread them, and set the
    268  1.10  christos 	 * pointer to NULL. Finally we unthread the entry, freeing it for
    269  1.10  christos 	 * further use.
    270  1.10  christos 	 *
    271  1.10  christos 	 * We don't call the destructor here, it is the responsibility
    272  1.10  christos 	 * of the application to cleanup the storage:
    273  1.10  christos 	 * 	http://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/9699919799/functions/\
    274  1.10  christos 	 *	pthread_key_delete.html
    275   1.9  christos 	 */
    276   1.9  christos 	struct pt_specific *pt;
    277   1.9  christos 
    278  1.11  christos 	if (__predict_false(__uselibcstub))
    279  1.11  christos 		return __libc_thr_keydelete_stub(key);
    280  1.11  christos 
    281  1.12      manu 	pthread__assert(key >= 0 && key < pthread_keys_max);
    282   1.9  christos 
    283   1.1   nathanw 	pthread_mutex_lock(&tsd_mutex);
    284   1.9  christos 
    285   1.9  christos 	pthread__assert(pthread__tsd_destructors[key] != NULL);
    286   1.9  christos 
    287   1.9  christos 	while ((pt = PTQ_FIRST(&pthread__tsd_list[key])) != NULL) {
    288   1.9  christos 		PTQ_REMOVE(&pthread__tsd_list[key], pt, pts_next);
    289   1.9  christos 		pt->pts_value = NULL;
    290   1.9  christos 		pt->pts_next.ptqe_prev = NULL;
    291   1.9  christos 	}
    292   1.9  christos 
    293   1.1   nathanw 	pthread__tsd_destructors[key] = NULL;
    294   1.1   nathanw 	pthread_mutex_unlock(&tsd_mutex);
    295   1.1   nathanw 
    296   1.1   nathanw 	return 0;
    297   1.1   nathanw }
    298   1.1   nathanw 
    299   1.1   nathanw /* Perform thread-exit-time destruction of thread-specific data. */
    300   1.1   nathanw void
    301   1.1   nathanw pthread__destroy_tsd(pthread_t self)
    302   1.1   nathanw {
    303   1.1   nathanw 	int i, done, iterations;
    304   1.1   nathanw 	void *val;
    305   1.1   nathanw 	void (*destructor)(void *);
    306   1.1   nathanw 
    307   1.3        ad 	if (!self->pt_havespecific)
    308   1.3        ad 		return;
    309   1.4        ad 	pthread_mutex_unlock(&self->pt_lock);
    310   1.3        ad 
    311   1.1   nathanw 	/* Butenhof, section 5.4.2 (page 167):
    312   1.1   nathanw 	 *
    313   1.1   nathanw 	 * ``Also, Pthreads sets the thread-specific data value for a
    314   1.1   nathanw 	 * key to NULL before calling that key's destructor (passing
    315   1.1   nathanw 	 * the previous value of the key) when a thread terminates [*].
    316   1.1   nathanw 	 * ...
    317   1.1   nathanw 	 * [*] That is, unfortunately, not what the standard
    318   1.1   nathanw 	 * says. This is one of the problems with formal standards -
    319   1.1   nathanw 	 * they say what they say, not what they were intended to
    320   1.1   nathanw 	 * say. Somehow, an error crept in, and the sentence
    321   1.1   nathanw 	 * specifying that "the implementation clears the
    322   1.1   nathanw 	 * thread-specific data value before calling the destructor"
    323   1.1   nathanw 	 * was deleted. Nobody noticed, and the standard was approved
    324   1.1   nathanw 	 * with the error. So the standard says (by omission) that if
    325   1.1   nathanw 	 * you want to write a portable application using
    326   1.1   nathanw 	 * thread-specific data, that will not hang on thread
    327   1.1   nathanw 	 * termination, you must call pthread_setspecific within your
    328   1.1   nathanw 	 * destructor function to change the value to NULL. This would
    329   1.1   nathanw 	 * be silly, and any serious implementation of Pthreads will
    330   1.1   nathanw 	 * violate the standard in this respect. Of course, the
    331   1.1   nathanw 	 * standard will be fixed, probably by the 1003.1n amendment
    332   1.1   nathanw 	 * (assorted corrections to 1003.1c-1995), but that will take
    333   1.1   nathanw 	 * a while.''
    334   1.1   nathanw 	 */
    335   1.1   nathanw 
    336  1.16  christos 	/* We're not required to try very hard */
    337  1.16  christos 	iterations = PTHREAD_DESTRUCTOR_ITERATIONS;
    338   1.1   nathanw 	do {
    339   1.1   nathanw 		done = 1;
    340  1.12      manu 		for (i = 0; i < pthread_keys_max; i++) {
    341   1.9  christos 			struct pt_specific *pt = &self->pt_specific[i];
    342   1.9  christos 			if (pt->pts_next.ptqe_prev == NULL)
    343   1.9  christos 				continue;
    344   1.9  christos 			pthread_mutex_lock(&tsd_mutex);
    345   1.9  christos 
    346   1.9  christos 			if (pt->pts_next.ptqe_prev != NULL)  {
    347   1.9  christos 				PTQ_REMOVE(&pthread__tsd_list[i], pt, pts_next);
    348   1.9  christos 				val = pt->pts_value;
    349   1.9  christos 				pt->pts_value = NULL;
    350   1.9  christos 				pt->pts_next.ptqe_prev = NULL;
    351   1.1   nathanw 				destructor = pthread__tsd_destructors[i];
    352   1.9  christos 			} else
    353   1.9  christos 				destructor = NULL;
    354   1.9  christos 
    355   1.9  christos 			pthread_mutex_unlock(&tsd_mutex);
    356   1.9  christos 			if (destructor != NULL) {
    357   1.9  christos 				done = 0;
    358   1.9  christos 				(*destructor)(val);
    359   1.1   nathanw 			}
    360   1.1   nathanw 		}
    361  1.16  christos 	} while (!done && --iterations);
    362   1.3        ad 
    363   1.3        ad 	self->pt_havespecific = 0;
    364   1.4        ad 	pthread_mutex_lock(&self->pt_lock);
    365   1.1   nathanw }
    366  1.17  christos 
    367  1.17  christos void
    368  1.17  christos pthread__copy_tsd(pthread_t self)
    369  1.17  christos {
    370  1.17  christos 	for (size_t key = 0; key < TSD_KEYS_MAX; key++) {
    371  1.17  christos 
    372  1.17  christos 		if (__libc_tsd[key].tsd_inuse == 0)
    373  1.17  christos 			continue;
    374  1.17  christos 
    375  1.17  christos 		pthread__assert(pthread__tsd_destructors[key] == NULL);
    376  1.17  christos 		pthread__tsd_destructors[key] = __libc_tsd[key].tsd_dtor ?
    377  1.17  christos 		    __libc_tsd[key].tsd_dtor : null_destructor;
    378  1.17  christos 		nextkey = (key + 1) % pthread_keys_max;
    379  1.17  christos 
    380  1.17  christos 		self->pt_havespecific = 1;
    381  1.17  christos 		struct pt_specific *pt = &self->pt_specific[key];
    382  1.17  christos 		pt->pts_value = __libc_tsd[key].tsd_val;
    383  1.17  christos 		__libc_tsd[key].tsd_inuse = 0;
    384  1.17  christos 	}
    385  1.17  christos }
    386