Home | History | Annotate | Line # | Download | only in veriexecgen
veriexecgen.c revision 1.14
      1  1.14   hubertf /* $NetBSD: veriexecgen.c,v 1.14 2007/01/16 17:32:04 hubertf Exp $ */
      2   1.1      elad 
      3   1.1      elad /*-
      4   1.1      elad  * Copyright (c) 2006 The NetBSD Foundation, Inc.
      5   1.1      elad  * All rights reserved.
      6   1.1      elad  *
      7   1.1      elad  * This code is derived from software contributed to The NetBSD Foundation
      8   1.1      elad  * by Matt Fleming.
      9   1.1      elad  *
     10   1.1      elad  * Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without
     11   1.1      elad  * modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions
     12   1.1      elad  * are met:
     13   1.1      elad  * 1. Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright
     14   1.1      elad  *    notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer.
     15   1.1      elad  * 2. Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright
     16   1.1      elad  *    notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in the
     17   1.1      elad  *    documentation and/or other materials provided with the distribution.
     18  1.13       mjf  * 3. Neither the name of The NetBSD Foundation nor the names of its
     19   1.1      elad  *    contributors may be used to endorse or promote products derived
     20   1.1      elad  *    from this software without specific prior written permission.
     21   1.1      elad  *
     22   1.1      elad  * THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE NETBSD FOUNDATION, INC. AND CONTRIBUTORS
     23   1.1      elad  * ``AS IS'' AND ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED
     24   1.1      elad  * TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR
     25   1.1      elad  * PURPOSE ARE DISCLAIMED.  IN NO EVENT SHALL THE FOUNDATION OR CONTRIBUTORS
     26   1.1      elad  * BE LIABLE FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR
     27   1.1      elad  * CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PROCUREMENT OF
     28   1.1      elad  * SUBSTITUTE GOODS OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, DATA, OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS
     29   1.1      elad  * INTERRUPTION) HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN
     30   1.1      elad  * CONTRACT, STRICT LIABILITY, OR TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE)
     31   1.1      elad  * ARISING IN ANY WAY OUT OF THE USE OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE
     32   1.1      elad  * POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGE.
     33   1.1      elad  */
     34  1.11       agc #if HAVE_NBTOOL_CONFIG_H
     35  1.11       agc #include "nbtool_config.h"
     36  1.11       agc #endif
     37  1.11       agc 
     38  1.11       agc #include <sys/cdefs.h>
     39  1.11       agc 
     40  1.11       agc #ifndef lint
     41  1.11       agc #ifdef __RCSID
     42  1.14   hubertf __RCSID("$NetBSD: veriexecgen.c,v 1.14 2007/01/16 17:32:04 hubertf Exp $");
     43  1.11       agc #endif
     44  1.11       agc #endif /* not lint */
     45  1.11       agc 
     46   1.1      elad #include <sys/param.h>
     47   1.1      elad #include <sys/types.h>
     48   1.1      elad #include <sys/queue.h>
     49   1.1      elad #include <sys/stat.h>
     50   1.1      elad #include <sys/dirent.h>
     51   1.1      elad #include <sys/verified_exec.h>
     52   1.1      elad 
     53   1.1      elad #include <err.h>
     54   1.1      elad #include <errno.h>
     55   1.1      elad #include <fts.h>
     56   1.1      elad #include <stdio.h>
     57   1.1      elad #include <stdlib.h>
     58   1.1      elad #include <string.h>
     59   1.1      elad #include <time.h>
     60   1.1      elad #include <unistd.h>
     61   1.1      elad #include <util.h>
     62   1.1      elad 
     63   1.1      elad #include <md5.h>
     64   1.2      elad #include <sha1.h>
     65   1.8  christos #include <sha2.h>
     66   1.8  christos #include <rmd160.h>
     67   1.1      elad 
     68   1.1      elad #define IS_EXEC(mode) ((mode) & (S_IXUSR | S_IXGRP | S_IXOTH))
     69   1.1      elad 
     70   1.1      elad #define DEFAULT_DBFILE  "/etc/signatures"
     71   1.1      elad #define DEFAULT_HASH    "sha256"
     72   1.1      elad #define DEFAULT_SYSPATHS { "/bin", "/sbin", "/usr/bin", "/usr/sbin", \
     73   1.6      elad 			   "/lib", "/usr/lib", "/libexec", "/usr/libexec", \
     74   1.6      elad 			   NULL }
     75   1.1      elad 
     76  1.11       agc /* this struct defines a hash algorithm */
     77  1.11       agc typedef struct hash_t {
     78  1.11       agc 	const char	*hashname;	/* algorithm name */
     79  1.11       agc 	char		*(*filefunc)(const char *, char *); /* function */
     80  1.11       agc } hash_t;
     81  1.11       agc 
     82  1.11       agc /* this struct encapsulates various diverse options and arguments */
     83  1.11       agc typedef struct veriexecgen_t {
     84  1.11       agc 	int	 all_files;	/* scan also for non-executable files */
     85  1.11       agc 	int	 append_output;	/* append output to existing sigs file */
     86  1.11       agc 	char	*dbfile;	/* name of signatures database file */
     87  1.11       agc 	int	 exit_on_error;	/* exit if we can't create a hash */
     88  1.11       agc 	char	*prefix;	/* any prefix to be discarded on output */
     89  1.11       agc 	int	 recursive_scan;/* perform scan for files recursively */
     90  1.11       agc 	int	 scan_system_dirs;	/* just scan system directories */
     91  1.11       agc 	int	 verbose;	/* verbosity level */
     92  1.11       agc } veriexecgen_t;
     93  1.11       agc 
     94  1.10       agc /* this struct describes a directory entry to generate a hash for */
     95   1.1      elad struct fentry {
     96  1.10       agc 	char filename[MAXPATHLEN];	/* name of entry */
     97  1.10       agc 	char *hash_val;			/* its associated hash value */
     98  1.10       agc 	int flags;			/* any associated flags */
     99  1.10       agc 	TAILQ_ENTRY(fentry) f;		/* its place in the queue */
    100   1.1      elad };
    101   1.1      elad TAILQ_HEAD(, fentry) fehead;
    102   1.1      elad 
    103  1.11       agc /* define the possible hash algorithms */
    104  1.11       agc static hash_t	 hashes[] = {
    105   1.1      elad 	{ "MD5", MD5File },
    106   1.1      elad 	{ "SHA1", SHA1File },
    107   1.1      elad 	{ "SHA256", SHA256_File },
    108   1.1      elad 	{ "SHA384", SHA384_File },
    109   1.1      elad 	{ "SHA512", SHA512_File },
    110   1.1      elad 	{ "RMD160", RMD160File },
    111   1.1      elad 	{ NULL, NULL },
    112   1.1      elad };
    113   1.1      elad 
    114  1.10       agc static int Fflag;
    115   1.9       agc 
    116  1.10       agc static int	make_immutable;	/* set immutable flag on signatures file */
    117   1.9       agc 
    118   1.9       agc /* warn about a problem - exit if exit_on_error is set */
    119   1.9       agc static void
    120  1.11       agc gripe(veriexecgen_t *vp, const char *fmt, const char *filename)
    121   1.9       agc {
    122   1.9       agc 	warn(fmt, filename);
    123  1.11       agc 	if (vp->exit_on_error) {
    124   1.9       agc 		/* error out on problematic files */
    125   1.9       agc 		exit(EXIT_FAILURE);
    126   1.9       agc 	}
    127   1.9       agc }
    128   1.1      elad 
    129  1.10       agc /* print usage message */
    130   1.1      elad static void
    131   1.1      elad usage(void)
    132   1.1      elad {
    133   1.1      elad 	(void)fprintf(stderr,
    134  1.12       wiz 	    "usage:  %s [-AaDrSvW] [-d dir] [-o fingerprintdb] [-p prefix]\n"
    135  1.12       wiz 	    "\t\t    [-t algorithm]\n"
    136  1.12       wiz 	    "\t%s [-h]\n", getprogname(), getprogname());
    137   1.1      elad }
    138   1.1      elad 
    139  1.10       agc /* tell people what we're doing - scan dirs, fingerprint etc */
    140   1.1      elad static void
    141  1.11       agc banner(veriexecgen_t *vp, hash_t *hash_type, char **search_path)
    142   1.1      elad {
    143   1.1      elad 	int j;
    144   1.1      elad 
    145   1.1      elad 	(void)printf("Fingerprinting ");
    146   1.1      elad 
    147   1.1      elad 	for (j = 0; search_path[j] != NULL; j++)
    148   1.1      elad 		(void)printf("%s ", search_path[j]);
    149   1.1      elad 
    150   1.1      elad 	(void)printf("(%s) (%s) using %s\n",
    151  1.11       agc 	    vp->all_files ? "all files" : "executables only",
    152  1.11       agc 	    vp->recursive_scan ? "recursive" : "non-recursive",
    153   1.1      elad 	    hash_type->hashname);
    154   1.1      elad }
    155   1.1      elad 
    156  1.10       agc /* find a hash algorithm, given its name */
    157  1.11       agc static hash_t *
    158   1.1      elad find_hash(char *hash_type)
    159   1.1      elad {
    160  1.11       agc 	hash_t *hash;
    161   1.1      elad 
    162   1.1      elad 	for (hash = hashes; hash->hashname != NULL; hash++)
    163   1.1      elad 		if (strcasecmp(hash_type, hash->hashname) == 0)
    164   1.1      elad 			return hash;
    165   1.1      elad 	return NULL;
    166   1.1      elad }
    167   1.1      elad 
    168  1.10       agc /* perform the hashing operation on `filename' */
    169   1.1      elad static char *
    170  1.11       agc do_hash(char *filename, hash_t * h)
    171   1.1      elad {
    172   1.1      elad 	return h->filefunc(filename, NULL);
    173   1.1      elad }
    174   1.1      elad 
    175  1.10       agc /* return flags for `path' */
    176   1.1      elad static int
    177   1.1      elad figure_flags(char *path, mode_t mode)
    178   1.1      elad {
    179   1.1      elad #ifdef notyet
    180   1.1      elad 	if (Fflag) {
    181   1.1      elad 		/* Try to figure out right flag(s). */
    182   1.1      elad 		return VERIEXEC_DIRECT;
    183  1.10       agc 	}
    184   1.1      elad #endif /* notyet */
    185   1.1      elad 
    186  1.10       agc 	return (IS_EXEC(mode)) ? 0 : VERIEXEC_FILE;
    187   1.1      elad }
    188   1.1      elad 
    189  1.10       agc /* check to see that we don't have a duplicate entry */
    190   1.1      elad static int
    191   1.1      elad check_dup(char *filename)
    192   1.1      elad {
    193   1.1      elad 	struct fentry *lwalk;
    194   1.1      elad 
    195   1.1      elad 	TAILQ_FOREACH(lwalk, &fehead, f) {
    196   1.1      elad 		if (strncmp(lwalk->filename, filename,
    197   1.1      elad 			    (unsigned long) MAXPATHLEN) == 0)
    198   1.1      elad 			return 1;
    199   1.1      elad 	}
    200   1.1      elad 
    201   1.1      elad 	return 0;
    202   1.1      elad }
    203   1.1      elad 
    204  1.10       agc /* add a new entry to the list for `file' */
    205   1.1      elad static void
    206  1.11       agc add_new_entry(veriexecgen_t *vp, FTSENT *file, hash_t *hash)
    207   1.1      elad {
    208   1.1      elad 	struct fentry *e;
    209   1.1      elad 	struct stat sb;
    210   1.1      elad 
    211   1.1      elad 	if (file->fts_info == FTS_SL) {
    212  1.10       agc 		/* we have a symbolic link */
    213   1.9       agc 		if (stat(file->fts_path, &sb) == -1) {
    214  1.11       agc 			gripe(vp, "Cannot stat symlink `%s'", file->fts_path);
    215   1.9       agc 			return;
    216   1.9       agc 		}
    217   1.1      elad 	} else
    218   1.1      elad 		sb = *file->fts_statp;
    219   1.1      elad 
    220  1.11       agc 	if (!vp->all_files && !vp->scan_system_dirs && !IS_EXEC(sb.st_mode))
    221   1.1      elad 		return;
    222   1.1      elad 
    223   1.1      elad 	e = ecalloc(1UL, sizeof(*e));
    224   1.1      elad 
    225   1.9       agc 	if (realpath(file->fts_accpath, e->filename) == NULL) {
    226  1.11       agc 		gripe(vp, "Cannot find absolute path `%s'", file->fts_accpath);
    227   1.9       agc 		return;
    228   1.9       agc 	}
    229   1.1      elad 	if (check_dup(e->filename)) {
    230   1.1      elad 		free(e);
    231   1.1      elad 		return;
    232   1.1      elad 	}
    233   1.9       agc 	if ((e->hash_val = do_hash(e->filename, hash)) == NULL) {
    234  1.11       agc 		gripe(vp, "Cannot calculate hash `%s'", e->filename);
    235   1.9       agc 		return;
    236   1.9       agc 	}
    237   1.1      elad 	e->flags = figure_flags(e->filename, sb.st_mode);
    238   1.1      elad 
    239   1.1      elad 	TAILQ_INSERT_TAIL(&fehead, e, f);
    240   1.1      elad }
    241   1.1      elad 
    242  1.10       agc /* walk through a directory */
    243   1.1      elad static void
    244  1.11       agc walk_dir(veriexecgen_t *vp, char **search_path, hash_t *hash)
    245   1.1      elad {
    246   1.1      elad 	FTS *fh;
    247   1.1      elad 	FTSENT *file;
    248   1.1      elad 
    249   1.9       agc 	if ((fh = fts_open(search_path, FTS_PHYSICAL, NULL)) == NULL) {
    250  1.11       agc 		gripe(vp, "fts_open `%s'", (const char *)search_path);
    251   1.9       agc 		return;
    252   1.9       agc 	}
    253   1.1      elad 
    254   1.1      elad 	while ((file = fts_read(fh)) != NULL) {
    255  1.11       agc 		if (!vp->recursive_scan && file->fts_level > 1) {
    256   1.1      elad 			fts_set(fh, file, FTS_SKIP);
    257   1.1      elad 			continue;
    258   1.1      elad 		}
    259   1.1      elad 
    260   1.1      elad 		switch (file->fts_info) {
    261   1.1      elad 		case FTS_D:
    262   1.1      elad 		case FTS_DC:
    263   1.1      elad 		case FTS_DP:
    264   1.1      elad 			continue;
    265   1.1      elad 		default:
    266   1.1      elad 			break;
    267   1.1      elad 		}
    268   1.1      elad 
    269   1.1      elad 		if (file->fts_errno) {
    270  1.11       agc 			if (vp->exit_on_error) {
    271  1.10       agc 				errx(EXIT_FAILURE, "%s: %s", file->fts_path,
    272  1.10       agc 				    strerror(file->fts_errno));
    273  1.10       agc 			}
    274  1.10       agc 		} else {
    275  1.11       agc 			add_new_entry(vp, file, hash);
    276   1.1      elad 		}
    277   1.1      elad 	}
    278   1.1      elad 
    279   1.1      elad 	fts_close(fh);
    280   1.1      elad }
    281   1.1      elad 
    282  1.10       agc /* return a string representation of the flags */
    283   1.1      elad static char *
    284   1.1      elad flags2str(int flags)
    285   1.1      elad {
    286  1.10       agc 	return (flags == 0) ? "" : "FILE, INDIRECT";
    287   1.1      elad }
    288   1.1      elad 
    289  1.10       agc /* store the list in the signatures file */
    290   1.1      elad static void
    291  1.11       agc store_entries(veriexecgen_t *vp, hash_t *hash)
    292   1.1      elad {
    293   1.1      elad 	FILE *fp;
    294   1.1      elad 	int move = 1;
    295   1.1      elad 	char old_dbfile[MAXPATHLEN];
    296   1.1      elad 	time_t ct;
    297   1.1      elad 	struct stat sb;
    298   1.1      elad 	struct fentry  *e;
    299  1.11       agc 	int	prefixc;
    300   1.1      elad 
    301  1.11       agc 	if (stat(vp->dbfile, &sb) != 0) {
    302   1.1      elad 		if (errno == ENOENT)
    303   1.1      elad 			move = 0;
    304   1.1      elad 		else
    305  1.11       agc 			err(EXIT_FAILURE, "could not stat %s", vp->dbfile);
    306   1.1      elad 	}
    307  1.11       agc 	if (move && !vp->append_output) {
    308  1.11       agc 		if (vp->verbose)
    309   1.1      elad 			(void)printf("\nBacking up existing fingerprint file "
    310  1.11       agc 			    "to \"%s.old\"\n\n", vp->dbfile);
    311   1.1      elad 
    312  1.11       agc 		if (snprintf(old_dbfile, MAXPATHLEN, "%s.old", vp->dbfile) <
    313  1.11       agc 		    strlen(vp->dbfile) + 4) {
    314  1.10       agc 			err(EXIT_FAILURE, "%s", old_dbfile);
    315   1.1      elad 		}
    316  1.11       agc 		if (rename(vp->dbfile, old_dbfile) == -1)
    317  1.10       agc 			err(EXIT_FAILURE, "could not rename file");
    318   1.1      elad 	}
    319   1.1      elad 
    320  1.11       agc 	prefixc = (vp->prefix == NULL) ? -1 : strlen(vp->prefix);
    321  1.11       agc 
    322  1.11       agc 	fp = efopen(vp->dbfile, vp->append_output ? "a" : "w+");
    323   1.1      elad 
    324   1.1      elad 	time(&ct);
    325   1.1      elad 	(void)fprintf(fp, "# Generated by %s, %.24s\n",
    326   1.1      elad 		getlogin(), ctime(&ct));
    327   1.1      elad 
    328   1.1      elad 	TAILQ_FOREACH(e, &fehead, f) {
    329  1.11       agc 		if (vp->verbose)
    330   1.1      elad 			(void)printf("Adding %s.\n", e->filename);
    331   1.1      elad 
    332  1.11       agc 
    333  1.11       agc 		(void)fprintf(fp, "%s %s %s %s\n",
    334  1.11       agc 			(prefixc < 0) ? e->filename : &e->filename[prefixc],
    335   1.1      elad 			hash->hashname, e->hash_val, flags2str(e->flags));
    336   1.1      elad 	}
    337   1.1      elad 
    338   1.1      elad 	(void)fclose(fp);
    339   1.1      elad 
    340  1.11       agc 	if (vp->verbose) {
    341  1.10       agc 		(void)printf("\n\n"
    342  1.10       agc "#############################################################\n"
    343  1.10       agc "  PLEASE VERIFY CONTENTS OF %s AND FINE-TUNE THE\n"
    344  1.10       agc "  FLAGS WHERE APPROPRIATE AFTER READING veriexecctl(8)\n"
    345  1.10       agc "#############################################################\n",
    346  1.11       agc 			vp->dbfile);
    347  1.10       agc 	}
    348   1.1      elad }
    349   1.1      elad 
    350   1.1      elad int
    351   1.1      elad main(int argc, char **argv)
    352   1.1      elad {
    353   1.1      elad 	int ch, total = 0;
    354   1.1      elad 	char **search_path = NULL;
    355  1.11       agc 	hash_t *hash = NULL;
    356  1.11       agc 	veriexecgen_t	v;
    357   1.1      elad 
    358  1.11       agc 	(void) memset(&v, 0x0, sizeof(v));
    359  1.10       agc 	make_immutable = 0;
    360  1.10       agc 	Fflag = 0;
    361   1.1      elad 
    362   1.9       agc 	/* error out if we have a dangling symlink or other fs problem */
    363  1.11       agc 	v.exit_on_error = 1;
    364   1.9       agc 
    365  1.11       agc 	while ((ch = getopt(argc, argv, "AaDd:ho:p:rSt:vW")) != -1) {
    366   1.1      elad 		switch (ch) {
    367   1.1      elad 		case 'A':
    368  1.11       agc 			v.append_output = 1;
    369   1.1      elad 			break;
    370   1.1      elad 		case 'a':
    371  1.11       agc 			v.all_files = 1;
    372   1.1      elad 			break;
    373   1.1      elad 		case 'D':
    374  1.11       agc 			v.scan_system_dirs = 1;
    375   1.1      elad 			break;
    376   1.1      elad 		case 'd':
    377   1.1      elad 			search_path = erealloc(search_path, sizeof(char *) *
    378   1.1      elad 			    (total + 1));
    379   1.1      elad 			search_path[total] = optarg;
    380   1.1      elad 			search_path[++total] = NULL;
    381   1.1      elad 			break;
    382   1.1      elad #ifdef notyet
    383   1.1      elad 		case 'F':
    384   1.1      elad 			Fflag = 1;
    385   1.1      elad 			break;
    386   1.1      elad #endif /* notyet */
    387   1.1      elad 		case 'h':
    388   1.1      elad 			usage();
    389  1.10       agc 			return EXIT_SUCCESS;
    390   1.1      elad 		case 'o':
    391  1.11       agc 			v.dbfile = optarg;
    392  1.11       agc 			break;
    393  1.11       agc 		case 'p':
    394  1.11       agc 			v.prefix = optarg;
    395   1.1      elad 			break;
    396   1.1      elad 		case 'r':
    397  1.11       agc 			v.recursive_scan = 1;
    398   1.1      elad 			break;
    399   1.3      elad 		case 'S':
    400  1.10       agc 			make_immutable = 1;
    401   1.3      elad 			break;
    402   1.1      elad 		case 't':
    403  1.10       agc 			if ((hash = find_hash(optarg)) == NULL) {
    404  1.10       agc 				errx(EXIT_FAILURE,
    405  1.10       agc 					"No such hash algorithm (%s)",
    406  1.10       agc 					optarg);
    407  1.10       agc 			}
    408   1.1      elad 			break;
    409   1.1      elad 		case 'v':
    410  1.11       agc 			v.verbose = 1;
    411   1.1      elad 			break;
    412   1.9       agc 		case 'W':
    413  1.11       agc 			v.exit_on_error = 0;
    414   1.9       agc 			break;
    415   1.1      elad 		default:
    416   1.1      elad 			usage();
    417  1.10       agc 			return EXIT_FAILURE;
    418   1.1      elad 		}
    419   1.1      elad 	}
    420   1.1      elad 
    421  1.11       agc 	if (v.dbfile == NULL)
    422  1.11       agc 		v.dbfile = DEFAULT_DBFILE;
    423   1.1      elad 
    424   1.1      elad 	if (hash == NULL) {
    425   1.1      elad 		if ((hash = find_hash(DEFAULT_HASH)) == NULL)
    426  1.10       agc 			errx(EXIT_FAILURE, "No hash algorithm");
    427   1.1      elad 	}
    428   1.1      elad 
    429   1.1      elad 	TAILQ_INIT(&fehead);
    430   1.1      elad 
    431   1.1      elad 	if (search_path == NULL)
    432  1.11       agc 		v.scan_system_dirs = 1;
    433   1.1      elad 
    434  1.11       agc 	if (v.scan_system_dirs) {
    435   1.1      elad 		char *sys_paths[] = DEFAULT_SYSPATHS;
    436   1.1      elad 
    437  1.11       agc 		if (v.verbose)
    438  1.11       agc 			banner(&v, hash, sys_paths);
    439  1.11       agc 		walk_dir(&v, sys_paths, hash);
    440   1.1      elad 	}
    441   1.1      elad 
    442   1.1      elad 	if (search_path != NULL) {
    443  1.11       agc 		if (v.verbose)
    444  1.11       agc 			banner(&v, hash, search_path);
    445  1.11       agc 		walk_dir(&v, search_path, hash);
    446   1.1      elad 	}
    447   1.1      elad 
    448  1.11       agc 	store_entries(&v, hash);
    449   1.1      elad 
    450  1.11       agc 	if (make_immutable && chflags(v.dbfile, SF_IMMUTABLE) != 0)
    451  1.10       agc 		err(EXIT_FAILURE, "Can't set immutable flag");
    452   1.3      elad 
    453  1.10       agc 	return EXIT_SUCCESS;
    454   1.1      elad }
    455