1 @c markers: BUG TODO 2 3 @c Copyright (C) 1988-2022 Free Software Foundation, Inc. 4 @c This is part of the GCC manual. 5 @c For copying conditions, see the file gcc.texi. 6 7 @node Passes 8 @chapter Passes and Files of the Compiler 9 @cindex passes and files of the compiler 10 @cindex files and passes of the compiler 11 @cindex compiler passes and files 12 @cindex pass dumps 13 14 This chapter is dedicated to giving an overview of the optimization and 15 code generation passes of the compiler. In the process, it describes 16 some of the language front end interface, though this description is no 17 where near complete. 18 19 @menu 20 * Parsing pass:: The language front end turns text into bits. 21 * Gimplification pass:: The bits are turned into something we can optimize. 22 * Pass manager:: Sequencing the optimization passes. 23 * IPA passes:: Inter-procedural optimizations. 24 * Tree SSA passes:: Optimizations on a high-level representation. 25 * RTL passes:: Optimizations on a low-level representation. 26 * Optimization info:: Dumping optimization information from passes. 27 @end menu 28 29 @node Parsing pass 30 @section Parsing pass 31 @cindex GENERIC 32 @findex lang_hooks.parse_file 33 The language front end is invoked only once, via 34 @code{lang_hooks.parse_file}, to parse the entire input. The language 35 front end may use any intermediate language representation deemed 36 appropriate. The C front end uses GENERIC trees (@pxref{GENERIC}), plus 37 a double handful of language specific tree codes defined in 38 @file{c-common.def}. The Fortran front end uses a completely different 39 private representation. 40 41 @cindex GIMPLE 42 @cindex gimplification 43 @cindex gimplifier 44 @cindex language-independent intermediate representation 45 @cindex intermediate representation lowering 46 @cindex lowering, language-dependent intermediate representation 47 At some point the front end must translate the representation used in the 48 front end to a representation understood by the language-independent 49 portions of the compiler. Current practice takes one of two forms. 50 The C front end manually invokes the gimplifier (@pxref{GIMPLE}) on each function, 51 and uses the gimplifier callbacks to convert the language-specific tree 52 nodes directly to GIMPLE before passing the function off to be compiled. 53 The Fortran front end converts from a private representation to GENERIC, 54 which is later lowered to GIMPLE when the function is compiled. Which 55 route to choose probably depends on how well GENERIC (plus extensions) 56 can be made to match up with the source language and necessary parsing 57 data structures. 58 59 BUG: Gimplification must occur before nested function lowering, 60 and nested function lowering must be done by the front end before 61 passing the data off to cgraph. 62 63 TODO: Cgraph should control nested function lowering. It would 64 only be invoked when it is certain that the outer-most function 65 is used. 66 67 TODO: Cgraph needs a gimplify_function callback. It should be 68 invoked when (1) it is certain that the function is used, (2) 69 warning flags specified by the user require some amount of 70 compilation in order to honor, (3) the language indicates that 71 semantic analysis is not complete until gimplification occurs. 72 Hum@dots{} this sounds overly complicated. Perhaps we should just 73 have the front end gimplify always; in most cases it's only one 74 function call. 75 76 The front end needs to pass all function definitions and top level 77 declarations off to the middle-end so that they can be compiled and 78 emitted to the object file. For a simple procedural language, it is 79 usually most convenient to do this as each top level declaration or 80 definition is seen. There is also a distinction to be made between 81 generating functional code and generating complete debug information. 82 The only thing that is absolutely required for functional code is that 83 function and data @emph{definitions} be passed to the middle-end. For 84 complete debug information, function, data and type declarations 85 should all be passed as well. 86 87 @findex rest_of_decl_compilation 88 @findex rest_of_type_compilation 89 @findex cgraph_finalize_function 90 In any case, the front end needs each complete top-level function or 91 data declaration, and each data definition should be passed to 92 @code{rest_of_decl_compilation}. Each complete type definition should 93 be passed to @code{rest_of_type_compilation}. Each function definition 94 should be passed to @code{cgraph_finalize_function}. 95 96 TODO: I know rest_of_compilation currently has all sorts of 97 RTL generation semantics. I plan to move all code generation 98 bits (both Tree and RTL) to compile_function. Should we hide 99 cgraph from the front ends and move back to rest_of_compilation 100 as the official interface? Possibly we should rename all three 101 interfaces such that the names match in some meaningful way and 102 that is more descriptive than "rest_of". 103 104 The middle-end will, at its option, emit the function and data 105 definitions immediately or queue them for later processing. 106 107 @node Gimplification pass 108 @section Gimplification pass 109 110 @cindex gimplification 111 @cindex GIMPLE 112 @dfn{Gimplification} is a whimsical term for the process of converting 113 the intermediate representation of a function into the GIMPLE language 114 (@pxref{GIMPLE}). The term stuck, and so words like ``gimplification'', 115 ``gimplify'', ``gimplifier'' and the like are sprinkled throughout this 116 section of code. 117 118 While a front end may certainly choose to generate GIMPLE directly if 119 it chooses, this can be a moderately complex process unless the 120 intermediate language used by the front end is already fairly simple. 121 Usually it is easier to generate GENERIC trees plus extensions 122 and let the language-independent gimplifier do most of the work. 123 124 @findex gimplify_function_tree 125 @findex gimplify_expr 126 @findex lang_hooks.gimplify_expr 127 The main entry point to this pass is @code{gimplify_function_tree} 128 located in @file{gimplify.cc}. From here we process the entire 129 function gimplifying each statement in turn. The main workhorse 130 for this pass is @code{gimplify_expr}. Approximately everything 131 passes through here at least once, and it is from here that we 132 invoke the @code{lang_hooks.gimplify_expr} callback. 133 134 The callback should examine the expression in question and return 135 @code{GS_UNHANDLED} if the expression is not a language specific 136 construct that requires attention. Otherwise it should alter the 137 expression in some way to such that forward progress is made toward 138 producing valid GIMPLE@. If the callback is certain that the 139 transformation is complete and the expression is valid GIMPLE, it 140 should return @code{GS_ALL_DONE}. Otherwise it should return 141 @code{GS_OK}, which will cause the expression to be processed again. 142 If the callback encounters an error during the transformation (because 143 the front end is relying on the gimplification process to finish 144 semantic checks), it should return @code{GS_ERROR}. 145 146 @node Pass manager 147 @section Pass manager 148 149 The pass manager is located in @file{passes.cc}, @file{tree-optimize.c} 150 and @file{tree-pass.h}. 151 It processes passes as described in @file{passes.def}. 152 Its job is to run all of the individual passes in the correct order, 153 and take care of standard bookkeeping that applies to every pass. 154 155 The theory of operation is that each pass defines a structure that 156 represents everything we need to know about that pass---when it 157 should be run, how it should be run, what intermediate language 158 form or on-the-side data structures it needs. We register the pass 159 to be run in some particular order, and the pass manager arranges 160 for everything to happen in the correct order. 161 162 The actuality doesn't completely live up to the theory at present. 163 Command-line switches and @code{timevar_id_t} enumerations must still 164 be defined elsewhere. The pass manager validates constraints but does 165 not attempt to (re-)generate data structures or lower intermediate 166 language form based on the requirements of the next pass. Nevertheless, 167 what is present is useful, and a far sight better than nothing at all. 168 169 Each pass should have a unique name. 170 Each pass may have its own dump file (for GCC debugging purposes). 171 Passes with a name starting with a star do not dump anything. 172 Sometimes passes are supposed to share a dump file / option name. 173 To still give these unique names, you can use a prefix that is delimited 174 by a space from the part that is used for the dump file / option name. 175 E.g. When the pass name is "ud dce", the name used for dump file/options 176 is "dce". 177 178 TODO: describe the global variables set up by the pass manager, 179 and a brief description of how a new pass should use it. 180 I need to look at what info RTL passes use first@enddots{} 181 182 @node IPA passes 183 @section Inter-procedural optimization passes 184 @cindex IPA passes 185 @cindex inter-procedural optimization passes 186 187 The inter-procedural optimization (IPA) passes use call graph 188 information to perform transformations across function boundaries. 189 IPA is a critical part of link-time optimization (LTO) and 190 whole-program (WHOPR) optimization, and these passes are structured 191 with the needs of LTO and WHOPR in mind by dividing their operations 192 into stages. For detailed discussion of the LTO/WHOPR IPA pass stages 193 and interfaces, see @ref{IPA}. 194 195 The following briefly describes the inter-procedural optimization (IPA) 196 passes, which are split into small IPA passes, regular IPA passes, 197 and late IPA passes, according to the LTO/WHOPR processing model. 198 199 @menu 200 * Small IPA passes:: 201 * Regular IPA passes:: 202 * Late IPA passes:: 203 @end menu 204 205 @node Small IPA passes 206 @subsection Small IPA passes 207 @cindex small IPA passes 208 A small IPA pass is a pass derived from @code{simple_ipa_opt_pass}. 209 As described in @ref{IPA}, it does everything at once and 210 defines only the @emph{Execute} stage. During this 211 stage it accesses and modifies the function bodies. 212 No @code{generate_summary}, @code{read_summary}, or @code{write_summary} 213 hooks are defined. 214 215 @itemize @bullet 216 @item IPA free lang data 217 218 This pass frees resources that are used by the front end but are 219 not needed once it is done. It is located in @file{tree.cc} and is described by 220 @code{pass_ipa_free_lang_data}. 221 222 @item IPA function and variable visibility 223 224 This is a local function pass handling visibilities of all symbols. This 225 happens before LTO streaming, so @option{-fwhole-program} should be ignored 226 at this level. It is located in @file{ipa-visibility.cc} and is described by 227 @code{pass_ipa_function_and_variable_visibility}. 228 229 @item IPA remove symbols 230 231 This pass performs reachability analysis and reclaims all unreachable nodes. 232 It is located in @file{passes.cc} and is described by 233 @code{pass_ipa_remove_symbols}. 234 235 @item IPA OpenACC 236 237 This is a pass group for OpenACC processing. It is located in 238 @file{tree-ssa-loop.cc} and is described by @code{pass_ipa_oacc}. 239 240 @item IPA points-to analysis 241 242 This is a tree-based points-to analysis pass. The idea behind this analyzer 243 is to generate set constraints from the program, then solve the resulting 244 constraints in order to generate the points-to sets. It is located in 245 @file{tree-ssa-structalias.cc} and is described by @code{pass_ipa_pta}. 246 247 @item IPA OpenACC kernels 248 249 This is a pass group for processing OpenACC kernels regions. It is a 250 subpass of the IPA OpenACC pass group that runs on offloaded functions 251 containing OpenACC kernels loops. It is located in 252 @file{tree-ssa-loop.cc} and is described by 253 @code{pass_ipa_oacc_kernels}. 254 255 @item Target clone 256 257 This is a pass for parsing functions with multiple target attributes. 258 It is located in @file{multiple_target.cc} and is described by 259 @code{pass_target_clone}. 260 261 @item IPA auto profile 262 263 This pass uses AutoFDO profiling data to annotate the control flow graph. 264 It is located in @file{auto-profile.cc} and is described by 265 @code{pass_ipa_auto_profile}. 266 267 @item IPA tree profile 268 269 This pass does profiling for all functions in the call graph. 270 It calculates branch 271 probabilities and basic block execution counts. It is located 272 in @file{tree-profile.cc} and is described by @code{pass_ipa_tree_profile}. 273 274 @item IPA free function summary 275 276 This pass is a small IPA pass when argument @code{small_p} is true. 277 It releases inline function summaries and call summaries. 278 It is located in @file{ipa-fnsummary.cc} and is described by 279 @code{pass_ipa_free_free_fn_summary}. 280 281 @item IPA increase alignment 282 283 This pass increases the alignment of global arrays to improve 284 vectorization. It is located in @file{tree-vectorizer.cc} 285 and is described by @code{pass_ipa_increase_alignment}. 286 287 @item IPA transactional memory 288 289 This pass is for transactional memory support. 290 It is located in @file{trans-mem.cc} and is described by 291 @code{pass_ipa_tm}. 292 293 @item IPA lower emulated TLS 294 295 This pass lowers thread-local storage (TLS) operations 296 to emulation functions provided by libgcc. 297 It is located in @file{tree-emutls.cc} and is described by 298 @code{pass_ipa_lower_emutls}. 299 300 @end itemize 301 302 @node Regular IPA passes 303 @subsection Regular IPA passes 304 @cindex regular IPA passes 305 306 A regular IPA pass is a pass derived from @code{ipa_opt_pass_d} that 307 is executed in WHOPR compilation. Regular IPA passes may have summary 308 hooks implemented in any of the LGEN, WPA or LTRANS stages (@pxref{IPA}). 309 310 @itemize @bullet 311 @item IPA whole program visibility 312 313 This pass performs various optimizations involving symbol visibility 314 with @option{-fwhole-program}, including symbol privatization, 315 discovering local functions, and dismantling comdat groups. It is 316 located in @file{ipa-visibility.cc} and is described by 317 @code{pass_ipa_whole_program_visibility}. 318 319 @item IPA profile 320 321 The IPA profile pass propagates profiling frequencies across the call 322 graph. It is located in @file{ipa-profile.cc} and is described by 323 @code{pass_ipa_profile}. 324 325 @item IPA identical code folding 326 327 This is the inter-procedural identical code folding pass. 328 The goal of this transformation is to discover functions 329 and read-only variables that have exactly the same semantics. It is 330 located in @file{ipa-icf.cc} and is described by @code{pass_ipa_icf}. 331 332 @item IPA devirtualization 333 334 This pass performs speculative devirtualization based on the type 335 inheritance graph. When a polymorphic call has only one likely target 336 in the unit, it is turned into a speculative call. It is located in 337 @file{ipa-devirt.cc} and is described by @code{pass_ipa_devirt}. 338 339 @item IPA constant propagation 340 341 The goal of this pass is to discover functions that are always invoked 342 with some arguments with the same known constant values and to modify 343 the functions accordingly. It can also do partial specialization and 344 type-based devirtualization. It is located in @file{ipa-cp.cc} and is 345 described by @code{pass_ipa_cp}. 346 347 @item IPA scalar replacement of aggregates 348 349 This pass can replace an aggregate parameter with a set of other parameters 350 representing part of the original, turning those passed by reference 351 into new ones which pass the value directly. It also removes unused 352 function return values and unused function parameters. This pass is 353 located in @file{ipa-sra.cc} and is described by @code{pass_ipa_sra}. 354 355 @item IPA constructor/destructor merge 356 357 This pass merges multiple constructors and destructors for static 358 objects into single functions. It's only run at LTO time unless the 359 target doesn't support constructors and destructors natively. The 360 pass is located in @file{ipa.cc} and is described by 361 @code{pass_ipa_cdtor_merge}. 362 363 @item IPA function summary 364 365 This pass provides function analysis for inter-procedural passes. 366 It collects estimates of function body size, execution time, and frame 367 size for each function. It also estimates information about function 368 calls: call statement size, time and how often the parameters change 369 for each call. It is located in @file{ipa-fnsummary.cc} and is 370 described by @code{pass_ipa_fn_summary}. 371 372 @item IPA inline 373 374 The IPA inline pass handles function inlining with whole-program 375 knowledge. Small functions that are candidates for inlining are 376 ordered in increasing badness, bounded by unit growth parameters. 377 Unreachable functions are removed from the call graph. Functions called 378 once and not exported from the unit are inlined. This pass is located in 379 @file{ipa-inline.cc} and is described by @code{pass_ipa_inline}. 380 381 @item IPA pure/const analysis 382 383 This pass marks functions as being either const (@code{TREE_READONLY}) or 384 pure (@code{DECL_PURE_P}). The per-function information is produced 385 by @code{pure_const_generate_summary}, then the global information is computed 386 by performing a transitive closure over the call graph. It is located in 387 @file{ipa-pure-const.cc} and is described by @code{pass_ipa_pure_const}. 388 389 @item IPA free function summary 390 391 This pass is a regular IPA pass when argument @code{small_p} is false. 392 It releases inline function summaries and call summaries. 393 It is located in @file{ipa-fnsummary.cc} and is described by 394 @code{pass_ipa_free_fn_summary}. 395 396 @item IPA reference 397 398 This pass gathers information about how variables whose scope is 399 confined to the compilation unit are used. It is located in 400 @file{ipa-reference.cc} and is described by @code{pass_ipa_reference}. 401 402 @item IPA single use 403 404 This pass checks whether variables are used by a single function. 405 It is located in @file{ipa.cc} and is described by 406 @code{pass_ipa_single_use}. 407 408 @item IPA comdats 409 410 This pass looks for static symbols that are used exclusively 411 within one comdat group, and moves them into that comdat group. It is 412 located in @file{ipa-comdats.cc} and is described by 413 @code{pass_ipa_comdats}. 414 415 @end itemize 416 417 @node Late IPA passes 418 @subsection Late IPA passes 419 @cindex late IPA passes 420 421 Late IPA passes are simple IPA passes executed after 422 the regular passes. In WHOPR mode the passes are executed after 423 partitioning and thus see just parts of the compiled unit. 424 425 @itemize @bullet 426 @item Materialize all clones 427 428 Once all functions from compilation unit are in memory, produce all clones 429 and update all calls. It is located in @file{ipa.cc} and is described by 430 @code{pass_materialize_all_clones}. 431 432 @item IPA points-to analysis 433 434 Points-to analysis; this is the same as the points-to-analysis pass 435 run with the small IPA passes (@pxref{Small IPA passes}). 436 437 @item OpenMP simd clone 438 439 This is the OpenMP constructs' SIMD clone pass. It creates the appropriate 440 SIMD clones for functions tagged as elemental SIMD functions. 441 It is located in @file{omp-simd-clone.cc} and is described by 442 @code{pass_omp_simd_clone}. 443 444 @end itemize 445 446 @node Tree SSA passes 447 @section Tree SSA passes 448 449 The following briefly describes the Tree optimization passes that are 450 run after gimplification and what source files they are located in. 451 452 @itemize @bullet 453 @item Remove useless statements 454 455 This pass is an extremely simple sweep across the gimple code in which 456 we identify obviously dead code and remove it. Here we do things like 457 simplify @code{if} statements with constant conditions, remove 458 exception handling constructs surrounding code that obviously cannot 459 throw, remove lexical bindings that contain no variables, and other 460 assorted simplistic cleanups. The idea is to get rid of the obvious 461 stuff quickly rather than wait until later when it's more work to get 462 rid of it. This pass is located in @file{tree-cfg.cc} and described by 463 @code{pass_remove_useless_stmts}. 464 465 @item OpenMP lowering 466 467 If OpenMP generation (@option{-fopenmp}) is enabled, this pass lowers 468 OpenMP constructs into GIMPLE. 469 470 Lowering of OpenMP constructs involves creating replacement 471 expressions for local variables that have been mapped using data 472 sharing clauses, exposing the control flow of most synchronization 473 directives and adding region markers to facilitate the creation of the 474 control flow graph. The pass is located in @file{omp-low.cc} and is 475 described by @code{pass_lower_omp}. 476 477 @item OpenMP expansion 478 479 If OpenMP generation (@option{-fopenmp}) is enabled, this pass expands 480 parallel regions into their own functions to be invoked by the thread 481 library. The pass is located in @file{omp-low.cc} and is described by 482 @code{pass_expand_omp}. 483 484 @item Lower control flow 485 486 This pass flattens @code{if} statements (@code{COND_EXPR}) 487 and moves lexical bindings (@code{BIND_EXPR}) out of line. After 488 this pass, all @code{if} statements will have exactly two @code{goto} 489 statements in its @code{then} and @code{else} arms. Lexical binding 490 information for each statement will be found in @code{TREE_BLOCK} rather 491 than being inferred from its position under a @code{BIND_EXPR}. This 492 pass is found in @file{gimple-low.cc} and is described by 493 @code{pass_lower_cf}. 494 495 @item Lower exception handling control flow 496 497 This pass decomposes high-level exception handling constructs 498 (@code{TRY_FINALLY_EXPR} and @code{TRY_CATCH_EXPR}) into a form 499 that explicitly represents the control flow involved. After this 500 pass, @code{lookup_stmt_eh_region} will return a non-negative 501 number for any statement that may have EH control flow semantics; 502 examine @code{tree_can_throw_internal} or @code{tree_can_throw_external} 503 for exact semantics. Exact control flow may be extracted from 504 @code{foreach_reachable_handler}. The EH region nesting tree is defined 505 in @file{except.h} and built in @file{except.cc}. The lowering pass 506 itself is in @file{tree-eh.cc} and is described by @code{pass_lower_eh}. 507 508 @item Build the control flow graph 509 510 This pass decomposes a function into basic blocks and creates all of 511 the edges that connect them. It is located in @file{tree-cfg.cc} and 512 is described by @code{pass_build_cfg}. 513 514 @item Find all referenced variables 515 516 This pass walks the entire function and collects an array of all 517 variables referenced in the function, @code{referenced_vars}. The 518 index at which a variable is found in the array is used as a UID 519 for the variable within this function. This data is needed by the 520 SSA rewriting routines. The pass is located in @file{tree-dfa.cc} 521 and is described by @code{pass_referenced_vars}. 522 523 @item Enter static single assignment form 524 525 This pass rewrites the function such that it is in SSA form. After 526 this pass, all @code{is_gimple_reg} variables will be referenced by 527 @code{SSA_NAME}, and all occurrences of other variables will be 528 annotated with @code{VDEFS} and @code{VUSES}; PHI nodes will have 529 been inserted as necessary for each basic block. This pass is 530 located in @file{tree-ssa.cc} and is described by @code{pass_build_ssa}. 531 532 @item Warn for uninitialized variables 533 534 This pass scans the function for uses of @code{SSA_NAME}s that 535 are fed by default definition. For non-parameter variables, such 536 uses are uninitialized. The pass is run twice, before and after 537 optimization (if turned on). In the first pass we only warn for uses that are 538 positively uninitialized; in the second pass we warn for uses that 539 are possibly uninitialized. The pass is located in @file{tree-ssa.cc} 540 and is defined by @code{pass_early_warn_uninitialized} and 541 @code{pass_late_warn_uninitialized}. 542 543 @item Dead code elimination 544 545 This pass scans the function for statements without side effects whose 546 result is unused. It does not do memory life analysis, so any value 547 that is stored in memory is considered used. The pass is run multiple 548 times throughout the optimization process. It is located in 549 @file{tree-ssa-dce.cc} and is described by @code{pass_dce}. 550 551 @item Dominator optimizations 552 553 This pass performs trivial dominator-based copy and constant propagation, 554 expression simplification, and jump threading. It is run multiple times 555 throughout the optimization process. It is located in @file{tree-ssa-dom.cc} 556 and is described by @code{pass_dominator}. 557 558 @item Forward propagation of single-use variables 559 560 This pass attempts to remove redundant computation by substituting 561 variables that are used once into the expression that uses them and 562 seeing if the result can be simplified. It is located in 563 @file{tree-ssa-forwprop.cc} and is described by @code{pass_forwprop}. 564 565 @item Copy Renaming 566 567 This pass attempts to change the name of compiler temporaries involved in 568 copy operations such that SSA->normal can coalesce the copy away. When compiler 569 temporaries are copies of user variables, it also renames the compiler 570 temporary to the user variable resulting in better use of user symbols. It is 571 located in @file{tree-ssa-copyrename.c} and is described by 572 @code{pass_copyrename}. 573 574 @item PHI node optimizations 575 576 This pass recognizes forms of PHI inputs that can be represented as 577 conditional expressions and rewrites them into straight line code. 578 It is located in @file{tree-ssa-phiopt.cc} and is described by 579 @code{pass_phiopt}. 580 581 @item May-alias optimization 582 583 This pass performs a flow sensitive SSA-based points-to analysis. 584 The resulting may-alias, must-alias, and escape analysis information 585 is used to promote variables from in-memory addressable objects to 586 non-aliased variables that can be renamed into SSA form. We also 587 update the @code{VDEF}/@code{VUSE} memory tags for non-renameable 588 aggregates so that we get fewer false kills. The pass is located 589 in @file{tree-ssa-alias.cc} and is described by @code{pass_may_alias}. 590 591 Interprocedural points-to information is located in 592 @file{tree-ssa-structalias.cc} and described by @code{pass_ipa_pta}. 593 594 @item Profiling 595 596 This pass instruments the function in order to collect runtime block 597 and value profiling data. Such data may be fed back into the compiler 598 on a subsequent run so as to allow optimization based on expected 599 execution frequencies. The pass is located in @file{tree-profile.cc} and 600 is described by @code{pass_ipa_tree_profile}. 601 602 @item Static profile estimation 603 604 This pass implements series of heuristics to guess propababilities 605 of branches. The resulting predictions are turned into edge profile 606 by propagating branches across the control flow graphs. 607 The pass is located in @file{tree-profile.cc} and is described by 608 @code{pass_profile}. 609 610 @item Lower complex arithmetic 611 612 This pass rewrites complex arithmetic operations into their component 613 scalar arithmetic operations. The pass is located in @file{tree-complex.cc} 614 and is described by @code{pass_lower_complex}. 615 616 @item Scalar replacement of aggregates 617 618 This pass rewrites suitable non-aliased local aggregate variables into 619 a set of scalar variables. The resulting scalar variables are 620 rewritten into SSA form, which allows subsequent optimization passes 621 to do a significantly better job with them. The pass is located in 622 @file{tree-sra.cc} and is described by @code{pass_sra}. 623 624 @item Dead store elimination 625 626 This pass eliminates stores to memory that are subsequently overwritten 627 by another store, without any intervening loads. The pass is located 628 in @file{tree-ssa-dse.cc} and is described by @code{pass_dse}. 629 630 @item Tail recursion elimination 631 632 This pass transforms tail recursion into a loop. It is located in 633 @file{tree-tailcall.cc} and is described by @code{pass_tail_recursion}. 634 635 @item Forward store motion 636 637 This pass sinks stores and assignments down the flowgraph closer to their 638 use point. The pass is located in @file{tree-ssa-sink.cc} and is 639 described by @code{pass_sink_code}. 640 641 @item Partial redundancy elimination 642 643 This pass eliminates partially redundant computations, as well as 644 performing load motion. The pass is located in @file{tree-ssa-pre.cc} 645 and is described by @code{pass_pre}. 646 647 Just before partial redundancy elimination, if 648 @option{-funsafe-math-optimizations} is on, GCC tries to convert 649 divisions to multiplications by the reciprocal. The pass is located 650 in @file{tree-ssa-math-opts.cc} and is described by 651 @code{pass_cse_reciprocal}. 652 653 @item Full redundancy elimination 654 655 This is a simpler form of PRE that only eliminates redundancies that 656 occur on all paths. It is located in @file{tree-ssa-pre.cc} and 657 described by @code{pass_fre}. 658 659 @item Loop optimization 660 661 The main driver of the pass is placed in @file{tree-ssa-loop.cc} 662 and described by @code{pass_loop}. 663 664 The optimizations performed by this pass are: 665 666 Loop invariant motion. This pass moves only invariants that 667 would be hard to handle on RTL level (function calls, operations that expand to 668 nontrivial sequences of insns). With @option{-funswitch-loops} it also moves 669 operands of conditions that are invariant out of the loop, so that we can use 670 just trivial invariantness analysis in loop unswitching. The pass also includes 671 store motion. The pass is implemented in @file{tree-ssa-loop-im.cc}. 672 673 Canonical induction variable creation. This pass creates a simple counter 674 for number of iterations of the loop and replaces the exit condition of the 675 loop using it, in case when a complicated analysis is necessary to determine 676 the number of iterations. Later optimizations then may determine the number 677 easily. The pass is implemented in @file{tree-ssa-loop-ivcanon.cc}. 678 679 Induction variable optimizations. This pass performs standard induction 680 variable optimizations, including strength reduction, induction variable 681 merging and induction variable elimination. The pass is implemented in 682 @file{tree-ssa-loop-ivopts.cc}. 683 684 Loop unswitching. This pass moves the conditional jumps that are invariant 685 out of the loops. To achieve this, a duplicate of the loop is created for 686 each possible outcome of conditional jump(s). The pass is implemented in 687 @file{tree-ssa-loop-unswitch.cc}. 688 689 Loop splitting. If a loop contains a conditional statement that is 690 always true for one part of the iteration space and false for the other 691 this pass splits the loop into two, one dealing with one side the other 692 only with the other, thereby removing one inner-loop conditional. The 693 pass is implemented in @file{tree-ssa-loop-split.cc}. 694 695 The optimizations also use various utility functions contained in 696 @file{tree-ssa-loop-manip.cc}, @file{cfgloop.cc}, @file{cfgloopanal.cc} and 697 @file{cfgloopmanip.cc}. 698 699 Vectorization. This pass transforms loops to operate on vector types 700 instead of scalar types. Data parallelism across loop iterations is exploited 701 to group data elements from consecutive iterations into a vector and operate 702 on them in parallel. Depending on available target support the loop is 703 conceptually unrolled by a factor @code{VF} (vectorization factor), which is 704 the number of elements operated upon in parallel in each iteration, and the 705 @code{VF} copies of each scalar operation are fused to form a vector operation. 706 Additional loop transformations such as peeling and versioning may take place 707 to align the number of iterations, and to align the memory accesses in the 708 loop. 709 The pass is implemented in @file{tree-vectorizer.cc} (the main driver), 710 @file{tree-vect-loop.cc} and @file{tree-vect-loop-manip.cc} (loop specific parts 711 and general loop utilities), @file{tree-vect-slp} (loop-aware SLP 712 functionality), @file{tree-vect-stmts.cc}, @file{tree-vect-data-refs.cc} and 713 @file{tree-vect-slp-patterns.cc} containing the SLP pattern matcher. 714 Analysis of data references is in @file{tree-data-ref.cc}. 715 716 SLP Vectorization. This pass performs vectorization of straight-line code. The 717 pass is implemented in @file{tree-vectorizer.cc} (the main driver), 718 @file{tree-vect-slp.cc}, @file{tree-vect-stmts.cc} and 719 @file{tree-vect-data-refs.cc}. 720 721 Autoparallelization. This pass splits the loop iteration space to run 722 into several threads. The pass is implemented in @file{tree-parloops.cc}. 723 724 Graphite is a loop transformation framework based on the polyhedral 725 model. Graphite stands for Gimple Represented as Polyhedra. The 726 internals of this infrastructure are documented in 727 @w{@uref{https://gcc.gnu.org/wiki/Graphite}}. The passes working on 728 this representation are implemented in the various @file{graphite-*} 729 files. 730 731 @item Tree level if-conversion for vectorizer 732 733 This pass applies if-conversion to simple loops to help vectorizer. 734 We identify if convertible loops, if-convert statements and merge 735 basic blocks in one big block. The idea is to present loop in such 736 form so that vectorizer can have one to one mapping between statements 737 and available vector operations. This pass is located in 738 @file{tree-if-conv.cc} and is described by @code{pass_if_conversion}. 739 740 @item Conditional constant propagation 741 742 This pass relaxes a lattice of values in order to identify those 743 that must be constant even in the presence of conditional branches. 744 The pass is located in @file{tree-ssa-ccp.cc} and is described 745 by @code{pass_ccp}. 746 747 A related pass that works on memory loads and stores, and not just 748 register values, is located in @file{tree-ssa-ccp.cc} and described by 749 @code{pass_store_ccp}. 750 751 @item Conditional copy propagation 752 753 This is similar to constant propagation but the lattice of values is 754 the ``copy-of'' relation. It eliminates redundant copies from the 755 code. The pass is located in @file{tree-ssa-copy.cc} and described by 756 @code{pass_copy_prop}. 757 758 A related pass that works on memory copies, and not just register 759 copies, is located in @file{tree-ssa-copy.cc} and described by 760 @code{pass_store_copy_prop}. 761 762 @item Value range propagation 763 764 This transformation is similar to constant propagation but 765 instead of propagating single constant values, it propagates 766 known value ranges. The implementation is based on Patterson's 767 range propagation algorithm (Accurate Static Branch Prediction by 768 Value Range Propagation, J. R. C. Patterson, PLDI '95). In 769 contrast to Patterson's algorithm, this implementation does not 770 propagate branch probabilities nor it uses more than a single 771 range per SSA name. This means that the current implementation 772 cannot be used for branch prediction (though adapting it would 773 not be difficult). The pass is located in @file{tree-vrp.cc} and is 774 described by @code{pass_vrp}. 775 776 @item Folding built-in functions 777 778 This pass simplifies built-in functions, as applicable, with constant 779 arguments or with inferable string lengths. It is located in 780 @file{tree-ssa-ccp.cc} and is described by @code{pass_fold_builtins}. 781 782 @item Split critical edges 783 784 This pass identifies critical edges and inserts empty basic blocks 785 such that the edge is no longer critical. The pass is located in 786 @file{tree-cfg.cc} and is described by @code{pass_split_crit_edges}. 787 788 @item Control dependence dead code elimination 789 790 This pass is a stronger form of dead code elimination that can 791 eliminate unnecessary control flow statements. It is located 792 in @file{tree-ssa-dce.cc} and is described by @code{pass_cd_dce}. 793 794 @item Tail call elimination 795 796 This pass identifies function calls that may be rewritten into 797 jumps. No code transformation is actually applied here, but the 798 data and control flow problem is solved. The code transformation 799 requires target support, and so is delayed until RTL@. In the 800 meantime @code{CALL_EXPR_TAILCALL} is set indicating the possibility. 801 The pass is located in @file{tree-tailcall.cc} and is described by 802 @code{pass_tail_calls}. The RTL transformation is handled by 803 @code{fixup_tail_calls} in @file{calls.cc}. 804 805 @item Warn for function return without value 806 807 For non-void functions, this pass locates return statements that do 808 not specify a value and issues a warning. Such a statement may have 809 been injected by falling off the end of the function. This pass is 810 run last so that we have as much time as possible to prove that the 811 statement is not reachable. It is located in @file{tree-cfg.cc} and 812 is described by @code{pass_warn_function_return}. 813 814 @item Leave static single assignment form 815 816 This pass rewrites the function such that it is in normal form. At 817 the same time, we eliminate as many single-use temporaries as possible, 818 so the intermediate language is no longer GIMPLE, but GENERIC@. The 819 pass is located in @file{tree-outof-ssa.cc} and is described by 820 @code{pass_del_ssa}. 821 822 @item Merge PHI nodes that feed into one another 823 824 This is part of the CFG cleanup passes. It attempts to join PHI nodes 825 from a forwarder CFG block into another block with PHI nodes. The 826 pass is located in @file{tree-cfgcleanup.cc} and is described by 827 @code{pass_merge_phi}. 828 829 @item Return value optimization 830 831 If a function always returns the same local variable, and that local 832 variable is an aggregate type, then the variable is replaced with the 833 return value for the function (i.e., the function's DECL_RESULT). This 834 is equivalent to the C++ named return value optimization applied to 835 GIMPLE@. The pass is located in @file{tree-nrv.cc} and is described by 836 @code{pass_nrv}. 837 838 @item Return slot optimization 839 840 If a function returns a memory object and is called as @code{var = 841 foo()}, this pass tries to change the call so that the address of 842 @code{var} is sent to the caller to avoid an extra memory copy. This 843 pass is located in @code{tree-nrv.cc} and is described by 844 @code{pass_return_slot}. 845 846 @item Optimize calls to @code{__builtin_object_size} 847 848 This is a propagation pass similar to CCP that tries to remove calls 849 to @code{__builtin_object_size} when the size of the object can be 850 computed at compile-time. This pass is located in 851 @file{tree-object-size.cc} and is described by 852 @code{pass_object_sizes}. 853 854 @item Loop invariant motion 855 856 This pass removes expensive loop-invariant computations out of loops. 857 The pass is located in @file{tree-ssa-loop.cc} and described by 858 @code{pass_lim}. 859 860 @item Loop nest optimizations 861 862 This is a family of loop transformations that works on loop nests. It 863 includes loop interchange, scaling, skewing and reversal and they are 864 all geared to the optimization of data locality in array traversals 865 and the removal of dependencies that hamper optimizations such as loop 866 parallelization and vectorization. The pass is located in 867 @file{tree-loop-linear.c} and described by 868 @code{pass_linear_transform}. 869 870 @item Removal of empty loops 871 872 This pass removes loops with no code in them. The pass is located in 873 @file{tree-ssa-loop-ivcanon.cc} and described by 874 @code{pass_empty_loop}. 875 876 @item Unrolling of small loops 877 878 This pass completely unrolls loops with few iterations. The pass 879 is located in @file{tree-ssa-loop-ivcanon.cc} and described by 880 @code{pass_complete_unroll}. 881 882 @item Predictive commoning 883 884 This pass makes the code reuse the computations from the previous 885 iterations of the loops, especially loads and stores to memory. 886 It does so by storing the values of these computations to a bank 887 of temporary variables that are rotated at the end of loop. To avoid 888 the need for this rotation, the loop is then unrolled and the copies 889 of the loop body are rewritten to use the appropriate version of 890 the temporary variable. This pass is located in @file{tree-predcom.cc} 891 and described by @code{pass_predcom}. 892 893 @item Array prefetching 894 895 This pass issues prefetch instructions for array references inside 896 loops. The pass is located in @file{tree-ssa-loop-prefetch.cc} and 897 described by @code{pass_loop_prefetch}. 898 899 @item Reassociation 900 901 This pass rewrites arithmetic expressions to enable optimizations that 902 operate on them, like redundancy elimination and vectorization. The 903 pass is located in @file{tree-ssa-reassoc.cc} and described by 904 @code{pass_reassoc}. 905 906 @item Optimization of @code{stdarg} functions 907 908 This pass tries to avoid the saving of register arguments into the 909 stack on entry to @code{stdarg} functions. If the function doesn't 910 use any @code{va_start} macros, no registers need to be saved. If 911 @code{va_start} macros are used, the @code{va_list} variables don't 912 escape the function, it is only necessary to save registers that will 913 be used in @code{va_arg} macros. For instance, if @code{va_arg} is 914 only used with integral types in the function, floating point 915 registers don't need to be saved. This pass is located in 916 @code{tree-stdarg.cc} and described by @code{pass_stdarg}. 917 918 @end itemize 919 920 @node RTL passes 921 @section RTL passes 922 923 The following briefly describes the RTL generation and optimization 924 passes that are run after the Tree optimization passes. 925 926 @itemize @bullet 927 @item RTL generation 928 929 @c Avoiding overfull is tricky here. 930 The source files for RTL generation include 931 @file{stmt.cc}, 932 @file{calls.cc}, 933 @file{expr.cc}, 934 @file{explow.cc}, 935 @file{expmed.cc}, 936 @file{function.cc}, 937 @file{optabs.cc} 938 and @file{emit-rtl.cc}. 939 Also, the file 940 @file{insn-emit.cc}, generated from the machine description by the 941 program @code{genemit}, is used in this pass. The header file 942 @file{expr.h} is used for communication within this pass. 943 944 @findex genflags 945 @findex gencodes 946 The header files @file{insn-flags.h} and @file{insn-codes.h}, 947 generated from the machine description by the programs @code{genflags} 948 and @code{gencodes}, tell this pass which standard names are available 949 for use and which patterns correspond to them. 950 951 @item Generation of exception landing pads 952 953 This pass generates the glue that handles communication between the 954 exception handling library routines and the exception handlers within 955 the function. Entry points in the function that are invoked by the 956 exception handling library are called @dfn{landing pads}. The code 957 for this pass is located in @file{except.cc}. 958 959 @item Control flow graph cleanup 960 961 This pass removes unreachable code, simplifies jumps to next, jumps to 962 jump, jumps across jumps, etc. The pass is run multiple times. 963 For historical reasons, it is occasionally referred to as the ``jump 964 optimization pass''. The bulk of the code for this pass is in 965 @file{cfgcleanup.cc}, and there are support routines in @file{cfgrtl.cc} 966 and @file{jump.cc}. 967 968 @item Forward propagation of single-def values 969 970 This pass attempts to remove redundant computation by substituting 971 variables that come from a single definition, and 972 seeing if the result can be simplified. It performs copy propagation 973 and addressing mode selection. The pass is run twice, with values 974 being propagated into loops only on the second run. The code is 975 located in @file{fwprop.cc}. 976 977 @item Common subexpression elimination 978 979 This pass removes redundant computation within basic blocks, and 980 optimizes addressing modes based on cost. The pass is run twice. 981 The code for this pass is located in @file{cse.cc}. 982 983 @item Global common subexpression elimination 984 985 This pass performs two 986 different types of GCSE depending on whether you are optimizing for 987 size or not (LCM based GCSE tends to increase code size for a gain in 988 speed, while Morel-Renvoise based GCSE does not). 989 When optimizing for size, GCSE is done using Morel-Renvoise Partial 990 Redundancy Elimination, with the exception that it does not try to move 991 invariants out of loops---that is left to the loop optimization pass. 992 If MR PRE GCSE is done, code hoisting (aka unification) is also done, as 993 well as load motion. 994 If you are optimizing for speed, LCM (lazy code motion) based GCSE is 995 done. LCM is based on the work of Knoop, Ruthing, and Steffen. LCM 996 based GCSE also does loop invariant code motion. We also perform load 997 and store motion when optimizing for speed. 998 Regardless of which type of GCSE is used, the GCSE pass also performs 999 global constant and copy propagation. 1000 The source file for this pass is @file{gcse.cc}, and the LCM routines 1001 are in @file{lcm.cc}. 1002 1003 @item Loop optimization 1004 1005 This pass performs several loop related optimizations. 1006 The source files @file{cfgloopanal.cc} and @file{cfgloopmanip.cc} contain 1007 generic loop analysis and manipulation code. Initialization and finalization 1008 of loop structures is handled by @file{loop-init.cc}. 1009 A loop invariant motion pass is implemented in @file{loop-invariant.cc}. 1010 Basic block level optimizations---unrolling, and peeling loops--- 1011 are implemented in @file{loop-unroll.cc}. 1012 Replacing of the exit condition of loops by special machine-dependent 1013 instructions is handled by @file{loop-doloop.cc}. 1014 1015 @item Jump bypassing 1016 1017 This pass is an aggressive form of GCSE that transforms the control 1018 flow graph of a function by propagating constants into conditional 1019 branch instructions. The source file for this pass is @file{gcse.cc}. 1020 1021 @item If conversion 1022 1023 This pass attempts to replace conditional branches and surrounding 1024 assignments with arithmetic, boolean value producing comparison 1025 instructions, and conditional move instructions. In the very last 1026 invocation after reload/LRA, it will generate predicated instructions 1027 when supported by the target. The code is located in @file{ifcvt.cc}. 1028 1029 @item Web construction 1030 1031 This pass splits independent uses of each pseudo-register. This can 1032 improve effect of the other transformation, such as CSE or register 1033 allocation. The code for this pass is located in @file{web.cc}. 1034 1035 @item Instruction combination 1036 1037 This pass attempts to combine groups of two or three instructions that 1038 are related by data flow into single instructions. It combines the 1039 RTL expressions for the instructions by substitution, simplifies the 1040 result using algebra, and then attempts to match the result against 1041 the machine description. The code is located in @file{combine.cc}. 1042 1043 @item Mode switching optimization 1044 1045 This pass looks for instructions that require the processor to be in a 1046 specific ``mode'' and minimizes the number of mode changes required to 1047 satisfy all users. What these modes are, and what they apply to are 1048 completely target-specific. The code for this pass is located in 1049 @file{mode-switching.cc}. 1050 1051 @cindex modulo scheduling 1052 @cindex sms, swing, software pipelining 1053 @item Modulo scheduling 1054 1055 This pass looks at innermost loops and reorders their instructions 1056 by overlapping different iterations. Modulo scheduling is performed 1057 immediately before instruction scheduling. The code for this pass is 1058 located in @file{modulo-sched.cc}. 1059 1060 @item Instruction scheduling 1061 1062 This pass looks for instructions whose output will not be available by 1063 the time that it is used in subsequent instructions. Memory loads and 1064 floating point instructions often have this behavior on RISC machines. 1065 It re-orders instructions within a basic block to try to separate the 1066 definition and use of items that otherwise would cause pipeline 1067 stalls. This pass is performed twice, before and after register 1068 allocation. The code for this pass is located in @file{haifa-sched.cc}, 1069 @file{sched-deps.cc}, @file{sched-ebb.cc}, @file{sched-rgn.cc} and 1070 @file{sched-vis.c}. 1071 1072 @item Register allocation 1073 1074 These passes make sure that all occurrences of pseudo registers are 1075 eliminated, either by allocating them to a hard register, replacing 1076 them by an equivalent expression (e.g.@: a constant) or by placing 1077 them on the stack. This is done in several subpasses: 1078 1079 @itemize @bullet 1080 @item 1081 The integrated register allocator (@acronym{IRA}). It is called 1082 integrated because coalescing, register live range splitting, and hard 1083 register preferencing are done on-the-fly during coloring. It also 1084 has better integration with the reload/LRA pass. Pseudo-registers spilled 1085 by the allocator or the reload/LRA have still a chance to get 1086 hard-registers if the reload/LRA evicts some pseudo-registers from 1087 hard-registers. The allocator helps to choose better pseudos for 1088 spilling based on their live ranges and to coalesce stack slots 1089 allocated for the spilled pseudo-registers. IRA is a regional 1090 register allocator which is transformed into Chaitin-Briggs allocator 1091 if there is one region. By default, IRA chooses regions using 1092 register pressure but the user can force it to use one region or 1093 regions corresponding to all loops. 1094 1095 Source files of the allocator are @file{ira.cc}, @file{ira-build.cc}, 1096 @file{ira-costs.cc}, @file{ira-conflicts.cc}, @file{ira-color.cc}, 1097 @file{ira-emit.cc}, @file{ira-lives}, plus header files @file{ira.h} 1098 and @file{ira-int.h} used for the communication between the allocator 1099 and the rest of the compiler and between the IRA files. 1100 1101 @cindex reloading 1102 @item 1103 Reloading. This pass renumbers pseudo registers with the hardware 1104 registers numbers they were allocated. Pseudo registers that did not 1105 get hard registers are replaced with stack slots. Then it finds 1106 instructions that are invalid because a value has failed to end up in 1107 a register, or has ended up in a register of the wrong kind. It fixes 1108 up these instructions by reloading the problematical values 1109 temporarily into registers. Additional instructions are generated to 1110 do the copying. 1111 1112 The reload pass also optionally eliminates the frame pointer and inserts 1113 instructions to save and restore call-clobbered registers around calls. 1114 1115 Source files are @file{reload.cc} and @file{reload1.cc}, plus the header 1116 @file{reload.h} used for communication between them. 1117 1118 @cindex Local Register Allocator (LRA) 1119 @item 1120 This pass is a modern replacement of the reload pass. Source files 1121 are @file{lra.cc}, @file{lra-assign.c}, @file{lra-coalesce.cc}, 1122 @file{lra-constraints.cc}, @file{lra-eliminations.cc}, 1123 @file{lra-lives.cc}, @file{lra-remat.cc}, @file{lra-spills.cc}, the 1124 header @file{lra-int.h} used for communication between them, and the 1125 header @file{lra.h} used for communication between LRA and the rest of 1126 compiler. 1127 1128 Unlike the reload pass, intermediate LRA decisions are reflected in 1129 RTL as much as possible. This reduces the number of target-dependent 1130 macros and hooks, leaving instruction constraints as the primary 1131 source of control. 1132 1133 LRA is run on targets for which TARGET_LRA_P returns true. 1134 @end itemize 1135 1136 @item Basic block reordering 1137 1138 This pass implements profile guided code positioning. If profile 1139 information is not available, various types of static analysis are 1140 performed to make the predictions normally coming from the profile 1141 feedback (IE execution frequency, branch probability, etc). It is 1142 implemented in the file @file{bb-reorder.cc}, and the various 1143 prediction routines are in @file{predict.cc}. 1144 1145 @item Variable tracking 1146 1147 This pass computes where the variables are stored at each 1148 position in code and generates notes describing the variable locations 1149 to RTL code. The location lists are then generated according to these 1150 notes to debug information if the debugging information format supports 1151 location lists. The code is located in @file{var-tracking.cc}. 1152 1153 @item Delayed branch scheduling 1154 1155 This optional pass attempts to find instructions that can go into the 1156 delay slots of other instructions, usually jumps and calls. The code 1157 for this pass is located in @file{reorg.cc}. 1158 1159 @item Branch shortening 1160 1161 On many RISC machines, branch instructions have a limited range. 1162 Thus, longer sequences of instructions must be used for long branches. 1163 In this pass, the compiler figures out what how far each instruction 1164 will be from each other instruction, and therefore whether the usual 1165 instructions, or the longer sequences, must be used for each branch. 1166 The code for this pass is located in @file{final.cc}. 1167 1168 @item Register-to-stack conversion 1169 1170 Conversion from usage of some hard registers to usage of a register 1171 stack may be done at this point. Currently, this is supported only 1172 for the floating-point registers of the Intel 80387 coprocessor. The 1173 code for this pass is located in @file{reg-stack.cc}. 1174 1175 @item Final 1176 1177 This pass outputs the assembler code for the function. The source files 1178 are @file{final.cc} plus @file{insn-output.cc}; the latter is generated 1179 automatically from the machine description by the tool @file{genoutput}. 1180 The header file @file{conditions.h} is used for communication between 1181 these files. 1182 1183 @item Debugging information output 1184 1185 This is run after final because it must output the stack slot offsets 1186 for pseudo registers that did not get hard registers. Source files 1187 are @file{dbxout.cc} for DBX symbol table format, @file{dwarfout.c} for 1188 DWARF symbol table format, files @file{dwarf2out.cc} and @file{dwarf2asm.cc} 1189 for DWARF2 symbol table format, and @file{vmsdbgout.cc} for VMS debug 1190 symbol table format. 1191 1192 @end itemize 1193 1194 @node Optimization info 1195 @section Optimization info 1196 @include optinfo.texi 1197